The Scariest Part of Andor

The Star Wars show nobody asked for is the best franchise offering since The Empire Strikes Back.

Bryan Jarrell / 11.8.22

In the 1983 Star Wars film Return of the Jedi, an unnamed character briefs the beleaguered rebellion on tragic news: the Emperor is building a new Death Star. It’s not until the novelization of the movie that she’s given the name Mon Mothma, a former galactic senator who now leads The Rebel Alliance. The sober leader commands the room with her poise and middle age, standing in stark opposition to the youthful heroes of the trilogy. She gets less than thirty seconds of airtime, but the gravity of her speech lingers as she reveals that “Many Bothans died to bring us this information.” 

While our heroes have just rescued Han Solo from his imprisonment by Jabba the Hutt, her throwaway line about the Bothans hints at a darker side to the dark side. The human toll of this galactic civil war is hidden from a franchise hoping to sell toys to kids. Behind the unseen scenes of their rebellion, there’s a trail of bodies left behind in the battle of subterfuge, espionage, and infiltration. That story, of course, can be told another day, once Luke, Han, Leia, and their friends defeat the Empire for good.

Fast forward to 2022, and it’s time to tell that story. The latest Star Wars show Andor dropped back in September on Disney+ to tepid expectations. It was the show nobody asked for, an exploration of the early days of the Rebellion based on the one-off Rogue One movie from 2016. Rogue One was actually really good, but in a sea of other mediocre properties, you can’t blame fans for not trusting The Mouse with new ideas. Other investments, like the sequel trilogy, Solo, Obi-Wan, and The Book of Boba Fett, have fizzled or drawn ire from long-time fans.

But Andor … it’s entirely possible that this Andor series is the best Star Wars property to come along since The Empire Strikes Back.

Strong words, but have you seen the show? It’s dark and adult and gritty and willing to explore the depths of just how bad the Empire can be. Disney brought in a team with experience crafting shows like House of Cards, The Bourne Identity, The Americans, and Succession to helm this Star Wars property. It’s an adult-oriented show that asks big questions, raises high stakes, and embraces moral complexity. This is not a show designed to sell action figures to kids, and the result is a sci-fi exploration of fascism that lands among classics like A Clockwork Orange, 1984, or George Lucas’s first sci-fi thriller, THX-1138. It’s like a big budget Emmy-winning HBO drama, but on Disney+. 

What makes the show so great? Over at the Ringer, Ben Lindbergh suggests that the show’s key strength is ditching the lightsabers and cartoony villains of the universe while focusing directly on the people who make the machinations of the Empire tick. The result, he argues, is a fascism that is eerily relatable:

The Star Wars franchise has long alluded to Nazi terminology, iconography, and history, from its “stormtroopers” to its officers’ uniforms to its Riefenstahl-ian rallies to its chancellor turned tyrant who declares himself Emperor. From the first scene of the first film, the Third Reich-esque Galactic Empire was always evil. But there was nothing “normal” about it: It was evil in an exaggerated, unambiguous way, one coded for kids who were watching George Lucas’s largely lighthearted tribute to Flash Gordon serials.

Darth Vader was huge, helmeted, and armored, distinguished by a booming voice, sinister breathing, and a penchant for Force-choking. Emperor Palpatine was cloaked, hooded, and disfigured, prone to cackling and shooting lightning from his fingertips. The sneering, foul-smelling Grand Moff Tarkin, the most superficially civil and non-superpowered of the Empire’s prominent evildoers, could and did destroy a planet with a moon-sized superweapon. The overtness of the threat the Empire posed to the protagonists made it seem, in a sense, less threatening to us. In a real world without Sith lords, Death Stars, and the dark side of the Force, a kid could watch Star Wars and imagine themselves safe.

The Empire of Andor is different. Darth Vader and the Death Star are somewhere off-screen — the former unmentioned, the latter also unacknowledged aside from a stray reference to Scarif. The Emperor is remote and voiceless, the unseen spider at the center of a galaxy-wide web. The villains of Andor’s Empire — the strands of the trap Palpatine has constructed to ensnare thousands of worlds — look more like Arendt’s depiction of Eichmann: bureaucratic careerists, ineffectual functionaries, and competent cogs who at first could be confused for the occupants of a cube farm or Zoom room near you. The actual machinery of the Empire’s oppression makes cameos, at most — a few TIE fighters, some scattered stormtroopers, a briefly glimpsed Star Destroyer. But what Arendt called the “intricate bureaucratic setup of the Nazi machinery of destruction” — that insidious side of the Empire is never far from view.

Lindbergh is right — the Empire depicted in Andor is chilling and recognizable. The soldiers have faces that aren’t hidden behind depersonalized stormtrooper helmets. The Empire’s commanders serve on bases with trophy wives and beautiful children. Weak men become “simps” for cruel and powerful women. Human life is cheap. The justice system is a farce. Torture is ratcheted up to 11. The sense of dread in the show is so potent because it is so relatable.

The tyranny of the Empire in this show also forces our heroes to abandon the white-hat black-hat iconography, or perhaps more accurately, blue-saber and red-saber iconography. Our burgeoning rebellion is filled with thieves and scoundrels and compassionless ideologues, all of them walking a tightrope between the fighting for the freedom of the galaxy and tempering the violence needed to bring it about. Rebels in this show are putting guns to the heads of children, working with mob bosses to launder money, and plotting the assassination of teammates they don’t trust. One of their leaders argues that they need to increase the suffering to wake the galaxy from its complacency and draw attention to the Empire’s oppression. As the evil of the story becomes more and more relatable, the good guys in the story are faced with increased moral complexity. None are righteous in the Rebellion — everyone has dirty hands. 

Star Wars has long resisted thoughtful Christian reflection. Compare it to Lord of the Rings, written by a devout Catholic writer who explored themes like hope, corruption, and the counterintuitive power of weakness. Or compare it to the Marvel Cinematic Universe, where heroes and villains are given humanizing backstories of grief, broken families, loss, and oppression. Both of these franchises explore what it means to be human and bear the burden of suffering, whether it’s the suffering we cause ourselves or the suffering a broken world places on us. Unlike most Star Wars properties, there is no “dark side” or “light side” to choose because they recognize both light and dark coexist in every human heart. Lord of the Rings and Marvel movies can make fantastic sermon illustrations and blog posts. But yours truly, a hyper-opinionated Star Wars nut, couldn’t find a darn thing to write about for this website in the Boba Fett or Obi-Wan shows from earlier this year, and not for lack of trying.

Andor, though, breaks the mold. Evil is not a thoroughly corrupted Emperor cackling from his Death Star throne, nor is it an asthmatic faceless space samurai with a broken heart. The evil at work in this new show is a fascist police state, a jealous boyfriend, incel culture, the prison industrial complex, religious intolerance, manipulative parents, sexism in the workplace, self-preservation, a heartless bureaucracy, and complacency to the suffering of others. It’s a list of sins that put Andor’s world squarely in our own, and the show is all the better for it. The Empire Strikes Back takes the unexpected tact of having the good guys lose, making them more human than they were at the start of the trilogy. Andor follows suit, allowing its characters to struggle and suffer as we would given their impossible situations.

Andor is fantastic precisely because we cannot relegate the show’s evil to a galaxy far far away. His world is our world with more spaceships and fewer droids. As the season barrels toward a close in the weeks to come, we’ll see if the show can offer us a satisfying resolution to the evils so powerfully presented. My money is on someone making a heroic sacrifice to rescue the repentant and redeem the sins of the galaxy, but we’ll have to wait and see until the end of the season.

 

subscribe to the Mockingbird newsletter

COMMENTS


4 responses to “The Scariest Part of Andor”

  1. Jason says:

    Good insights here!

  2. […] realistic depictions of evil were going to require realistic resolutions — probably “involving someone making a heroic sacrifice to rescue the repentant and redeem the sins of the galax….” Now that the first season has finished, I’ll give myself two pats on the back for not being […]

  3. […] which would be hyperbole if it wasn’t true. Check out his two-part series, “The Scariest Part of Andor” and “How to Fight Evil According to Andor (and […]

  4. […] to the Star Wars universe since “The Empire Strikes Back,” and also, it’s the most Mbird worthy entry to the Star Wars canon to date. The trailer above gave me chills: from the “gimme […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *