The Sin That Endures Within

Robert Eggers’ Nosferatu and the Problem of Evil

Jeb Ralston / 1.9.25

Martin Luther once argued that original sin ran too deep for it to ever be fully extinguished in a person; he called it the “peccatum radicale” — the root sin.[1] For Luther, this sin “remains and at the same time it does not remain.” It is removed by God and yet also remains unremoved.[2] This paradox is one in which I have long been possessed, and I was surprised to see this dark mystery at the heart of Robert Eggers’ latest film, Nosferatu (2024).

Eggers made his first major directorial debut ten years ago with his religious horror The Witch (2015), and even he has noted the striking parallels between his earliest and most recent films. Both involve a young female protagonist coming (quite literally) face-to-face and bargaining with the devil. This time, however, instead of consenting to the devil’s bargain (as the lead character did in The Witch), Ellen, the tortured protagonist of Eggers’ latest, is forced into a relentless and embarrassingly intimate conflict with the embodiment of her own desires, with her own melancholy, and with the very real shadow of death: Nosferatu. Ellen laments her internal and external war in the simplest of terms: “Does evil come from within us or from beyond?”

While the former film takes place in seventeenth-century New England in the throes of the ever-present threat of witches and the devil’s devices, Nosferatu exists (as did the original film) in the enlightened world of the nineteenth century. The intellectual context of Nosferatu is one in which the demonic could be easily explained away through reason and scientific explanation. Yet, this adaptation of Nosferatu is infused with Eggers’ own fascination with a historical world imbued with meaning and ritual and the inexplicable. He said in a previous interview on his film The Northman (2022) that one of the fascinations he has with creating historical films is the allowance it gives for exploring a worldview “where everything around them is full of meaning,” as opposed to our “tiresome, lame, commercial culture” today with its obsession with the self and self-derived meaning.[3] It is at this very point that Nosferatu poses a striking criticism to both the skeptical rationalist and the optimistic romantic.

One character especially, Professor Albin Eberhart von Franz (played by the terrific Willem Dafoe), is especially poised to address the weird happenings besetting Ellen, taking the evil plaguing her at face value. In one critical point of the film he says:

I have seen things in this world that would’ve made Isaac Newton crawl back into his mother’s womb. We have not become so enlightened as we have been blinded by the gaseous light of science. I have wrestled with the devil as Jacob wrestled the angel in Peniel. And I tell you, if we are to tame darkness, we must first face that it exists.

Various characters are assaulted with evil before their very eyes yet refuse to name it as such. Ellen’s fight with Orlok (Nosferatu) is diagnosed by others as merely “hysterical fits” (despite even the act of levitation), yet it is the Professor who sees past such illusions and at one point tells Ellen that she is uniquely capable of confronting Nosferatu because she knows of the evil within herself and can use it against him. If Albin exposes rationalism’s blindness to the evil beyond, Ellen exposes herself as a rejection of romanticism’s disavowal of the evil within.

Ellen throughout this entire movie is caught somewhere between consenting to her own psychosexual desires and fiercely resisting the darkness that plagues her. She knows better than any other character that confronting Evil requires a confrontation with and a confession of the state of one’s own corrupt nature. Only the willing sacrifice of a fair maiden could defeat the Nosferatu, as the Professor instructed her, and yet Ellen knew her own will in the matter to be anything but wholly fair.

Nevertheless, if there is any “hero” in Nosferatu it must be Ellen, but much like Frodo in The Lord of the Rings, Ellen is a failed hero pressed beyond her creaturely limit. Both are righteous failures. Tolkien, like Eggers, was also infatuated with creating an elaborate world of meaning and mythology. Tolkien himself recognized that Frodo could not totally endure in his task until the very end. He was too weak, and his success was ultimately a mercy bestowed by a divine hand.

Tolkien writes about this in a letter dated to 1963. It is worth reading in its entirety, but this excerpt is especially telling:

Frodo indeed “failed” as a hero, as conceived by simple minds: he did not endure to the end; he gave in, ratted. […] I do not think that Frodo’s was a moral failure. At the last moment the pressure of the Ring would reach its maximum – impossible, I should have said, for any one to resist, certainly after long possession, months of increasing torment, and when starved and exhausted. Frodo had done what he could and spent himself completely (as an instrument of Providence) and had produced a situation in which the object of his quest could be achieved. His humility (with which he began) and his sufferings were justly rewarded by the highest honour; and his exercise of patience and mercy towards Gollum gained him Mercy: his failure was redressed. We are finite creatures with absolute limitations upon the powers of our soul-body structure in either action or endurance. […] Nonetheless, I think it can be observed in history and experience that some individuals seem to be placed in “sacrificial” positions: situations or tasks that for perfection of solution demand powers beyond their utmost limits, even beyond all possible limits for an incarnate creature in a physical world – in which a body may be destroyed, or so maimed that it affects the mind and will.[4]

Frodo and Ellen are not your typical modern heroes who find success through extreme willpower and sheer individual resilience, overcoming an impossibly one-sided situation. In Eggers’ and Tolkien’s worlds, there are powers at play that are ultimately more powerful than any human capacity. The human will is finite and faltering, and Frodo and Ellen can be viewed as heroes only through the lens of something greater than their own shortcomings.

Eggers’ greatest strength as a filmmaker is his ability to construct other worlds and allow them to be judged on their own terms. This is why historians (like myself and many I know) tend to enjoy his movies. He does not discredit past portraits of the world but allows them to speak for themselves in strange, dark, and frequently disturbing ways. Eggers recently said that his intention with rebooting this classic monster movie was not to offer cheap scares to his audience, but to “push” his viewers by building an atmosphere able  “[t]o probe the dark within us in a real way, to go back to those childhood instincts with a more adult approach.”[5] The great horror of Nosferatu is not simply Orlok himself, but the self-contradictory nature of one’s own desires: desiring what we know will kill us and at the same time wanting to kill the corruption of our own desires. Ellen and Eggers may have well been asking the Apostle Paul’s own question: “Who will deliver me from this body of death?”

Nosferatu is good horror because it unveils a universal and intimate reality. It reckons with a difficult truth: evil is real and it is familiar. But the film is also a surprisingly redemptive horror. As demonstrated by Ellen’s final resolve, there is an eternal light beyond every shadow, a divine mercy that can use even a shattered will, and a hidden providence which in some marvelous and mysterious way is capable of transmuting even the ghastliest sacrilege into a bloody sacrifice over evil itself.

 


[1] Luther, Lectures on Romans in LW 25.264–265; WA 56.277–278.

[2] Luther, Lectures on Romans in LW 25.258; WA 56.270.10–11, 13: “Simul manet peccatum et non manet. […] Simul tollitur eorum peccatum et non tollitur.”

[3] https://www.slashfilm.com/890207/the-northman-director-robert-eggers-is-glad-to-have-an-outlet-for-his-darkness-interview/

[4] https://www.tolkienestate.com/letters/letter-to-eileen-elgar-september-1963/

[5] https://www.anothermag.com/design-living/15891/robert-eggers-interview-nosferatu

subscribe to the Mockingbird newsletter

COMMENTS


One response to “The Sin That Endures Within”

  1. Ian says:

    Jeb, I’m so glad you brought Frodo into parallel with Ellen, it’s so apt. The strange thing is that Ellen’s Sauron is also perhaps her Gollum? The question that still troubles me from this film is, “Did she overcome evil? Or was she overcome by evil?” because the answer seems to be Yes.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *