Osama bin Laden and The Closed Circle of the Law

We normally hesitate to comment on political matters. Fortunately, the reaction to the death of […]

Mockingbird / 5.3.11

We normally hesitate to comment on political matters. Fortunately, the reaction to the death of Osama bin Laden goes beyond those parameters. Paul Walker, rector of Christ Church here in Charlottesville and main speaker at our Fall conference in Birmingham (10/28-29), has the following wise words:

“Do not rejoice when your enemy falls, and let not your heart be glad when he stumbles”  Proverbs 24:17

There is a deep irony in America’s unqualified jubilation over Osama Bin Laden’s assassination. Bin Laden’s death comes right on the heels of Holy Week. The hamster wheel of retributive justice was finally broken by God meeting violence, not with violence, but with acquiescence.

The closed circle of the Law – an eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth– was finally broken wide open. The Stone of the Law that sealed the tomb of humanity, a humanity formerly consigned to the drudgery of quid pro quo, was rolled away to let the sunrise of grace and mercy and forgiveness shine in. “Let the sunshine in.” The warmth of that graceful sun raises us to life – new life. We are now people sent out into the world in love. “As the Father has sent me, so I send you.”

So, for me, the pictures of young men right out of college, raising their beers and their flags around the Capitol, are portraits of people back in the darkness of the tomb. The message of Holy Week is without nuance: Might will never make right, and those who take up the sword will perish by the sword.

This week last year Paul preached an inspired and courageous sermon somewhat along these lines to the undergraduates of The University of Virginia, “A Sermon for George and Yeardley.” A couple of other worthy responses to bin Laden’s death come from David Sessions over at Patrol Mag, writing about the “celebrations” in NYC, “Frat Party in the USA,” and Andrew Sullivan on The Daily Beast who had the cajones (and great compassion) to write:

I pray tonight for the souls of the departed who died that awful day, and all their family members and friends. I pray for the souls of those great Americans who resisted on Flight 93. I pray for all those who have died in the two wars that followed this atrocity. As a Christian, I am also required to pray for the soul of Osama bin Laden. Yes, even him.

subscribe to the Mockingbird newsletter

COMMENTS


9 responses to “Osama bin Laden and The Closed Circle of the Law”

  1. honeybee says:

    Thank you for this.

    Seeing those pictures on television made me ashamed to be an American.

  2. Ken says:

    Great post, thanks. Joe Carter made the same basic point and started a long debate over on the First Things blog First Thoughts in a post entitled “Anthropos, Enemy, and Bin Laden.”

  3. John Zahl says:

    Along similar lines, a fellow Mockingbird posted this quote from MLK, Jr. yesterday on fb:

    I mourn the loss of thousands of precious lives, but I will not rejoice in the death of one, not even an enemy. Returning hate for hate multiplies hate, adding deeper darkness to a night already devoid of stars. Darkness cannot drive out darkness: only light can do that. Hate cannot drive out hate: only love can do that.”

  4. frat boy says:

    I looked here first for the right response to the images I was seeing on CNN and NYT, and I was psyched when you finally got the post up. I don’t currently have a blog or other venue for distributing this kind of message, but I’m glad you do because you have to look for it (another good one, and commentary on sports culture: http://www.bagnewsnotes.com/2011/05/bin-ladin-take-em-out-at-the-ball-game-or-the-jersey-pop/).

    I’ll also add that I’m a frat boy and while I cherish the relationships I share with some of my bretheren, I had to step outside my home (the frat) to get away from the chants of U-S-A. I’m allergic to short political slogans being chanted en masse to celebrate death and destruction, whoever’s getting destroyed.

  5. bls says:

    I kind of think we would have seen the very same celebrations had he been captured – so I don’t think that most of the jubilation is because of his death, but because he was “taken off the streets.” You saw the same kinds of celebrations after Japan surrendered at the end of WWII, in fact – after an atomic bomb had been dropped on the civilian population, who were really innocent of wrongdoing, as Bin Laden was not.

    Perhaps some are indeed celebrating his death – but I don’t think that’s the rule. It’s because people think a certain kind of madness has been overcome. Because that’s what people saw on 9/11 – madness; and I think that was the whole idea, actually. Plowing jetliners full of people into office buildings full of people was a move calculated to drive people mad with horror and grief.

    In fact, I think it’s remarkable that we saw so little violence after the event – that people did not act out more in rage afterwards.

    So I’m not sure what we’ve seen is as simple as all that. I could be wrong, of course.

  6. joshua says:

    For government is God’s servant for your good. But if you do wrong, be afraid, because it does not carry the sword for no reason. For government is God’s servant, an avenger that brings wrath on the one who does wrong. -Romans 13

    I suppose since governments are not longer suppose to exercise justice (according to the above rector) than we should release all those currently in our jails. Solves the problem of overcrowding.

  7. Ken says:

    Joshua, Paul isn’t saying that governments shouldn’t work for justice, and in “A Sermon for George and Yeardley,” linked above, and preached after a horrible murder here in Charlottesville, he explicitly says that he believes in punishment. I think his point is best understood through the proverb at the beginning of the post. It’s one thing to rejoice that evil is vanquished and that justice is done – these both glorify God. It’s quite another thing to cheer at the punishment itself, given that we all deserve death for our sins, but have been shown mercy, and that, as we see in the parable of the lost sheep, God grieves when souls are lost.

  8. John Rolfe Powell, Jr. says:

    Please, I am an American. I agree with this article, but I believe the opening sentence should read many in America and not “America’s unqualified jubilation” When I was born again I began to see people as individuals after spending time in the scriptures. In this country there is more freedom than the world is accustomed to. I do not take responsibility for those who are jubilant and I do not feel “ashamed” to be an American.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *