Is Kelly Clarkson Actually OK?

As many times as she insists “I’m fine,” one wonders whether it’s really true.

Sarah Gates / 11.29.23

In 2019, listening to a playlist of pop anthems while running out the clock on an elliptical machine, I realized that Kelly Clarkson had many wise things to say. Her lyrics hit almost like advice columns, cautioning lovers everywhere; in “Already Gone,” for example, Clarkson sings: “You couldn’t have loved me better / But I want you to move on, so I’m already gone.” Each song is filled with wisdom nuggets from a sage who has lived to tell (or sing) the tale.

Several years and a tornado-like heartbreak later (it picked me up and put my metaphorical house elsewhere; it also destroyed that house), I now experience some of the anthemic Clarkson hits as oppressively self-reliant. Consider, for example, “Since U Been Gone” (“Since you been gone / I can breathe for the first time”) and, especially, “Stronger”: “You know the bed feels warmer sleeping here alone” (I mean, does it, though? Do you have an extremely effective electric blanket that we’re not aware of?). At times, Clarkson seems to be very loudly beating a certain drum, to the tune of something like: “LISTEN GUYS (and maybe also “listen self?”) I’M FINE; I’M REALLY, REALLY FINE.” The delivery of this thesis is so emphatic that it almost sounds as if Clarkson has been taken hostage, and I begin to wonder: are you actually all that fine?

Throughout her career, Clarkson has demonstrated that she, like Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix‘s Cho Chang, can have more than one feeling at a time. Alongside self-reliant anthems, Clarkson has delivered hits that reveal a raw core. In “Because of You,” Clarkson sings: “Because of you / I never stray too far from the sidewalk.” A relationship has affected her to the extent that she is (at least metaphorically) avoiding roads.

Indeed, in reference to Clarkson’s latest album, the Grammy-nominated chemistry, I texted a friend that it was “good,” that the songs were “intense,” but that, in my view, Clarkson could carry that intensity. I’d heard one of the singles, “mine,” for the second time in a shop that day and made a note to look it up. A banger with a late time signature change, “mine’s” lyrics present an inherent contradiction: “Go ahead and break my heart, that’s fine … Eternal sunshine of the spotless mind.” It’s fine, but Clarkson might like to erase her own memory. Moreover, the song’s vengeful throughline suggests that it’s not actually all that fine; Clarkson sings: “I hope one day someone will take your heart and hold it tight … And right when you think that it’s perfect, they cross a line.”

“Mine” was released alongside the similarly titled but very differently written single “me.” In an Instagram post, Clarkson explained her rationale for releasing these two songs simultaneously: “… I didn’t want to release just one song to represent an entire album, or relationship … A whole relationship shouldn’t be just brought down to one thing. So there’s the good, the bad, and the ugly kinda thing going on.” Justin Curto, writing for Vulture, presents the songs as different takes on Clarkson’s 2020 divorce, describing “me” as “a self-reliant pick-me-up from Miss Independent herself.” Indeed, “me” harkens back to Clarkson’s more familiar “but really I’m fine” territory. She sings, with a full gospel choir backing her: “I don’t need somebody to hold me / Don’t need somebody to love me / … Don’t need to need somebody / When I got me.”

At this point in the album, I begin to have questions, chief among them: “You don’t need somebody to love you?” [Takes a beat.] How? Are we talking exclusively about human love, to the exclusion of divine love? Does canine love count? Kelly: Do you have a boatload of dogs, and that’s why you “don’t need somebody to love you?” Most importantly, ARE YOU OK???

As a relentless pessimist (I’M FINE), I just can’t take it. Honey drips down my throat, and soon, I’m coughing; rain floods my four walls, and I’m drowning. The positivity and denialism are too oppressive, and to be honest, confusing, in the larger context of the album.

Having the feeling “I don’t need somebody to love me” is one thing; belting it is another. Out of context, it reads like an f-you to God just as much as anyone, calling to mind the Israelites’ creation and worship of a golden calf while Moses is on Mt. Sinai. Arguably, the entire album could be read as a faith and doubt journey. Throughout, Clarkson expresses immense suffering; she expresses doubt in (and hate of!) love and faith in herself; by the end (and throughout), she expresses a renewed, but reconstructed faith in love.

“I’m such a great compartmentalizer,” Clarkson explained (humble-bragged?) in a 2023 interview on Watch What Happens Live. This self-aware nod to her own compartmentalization helps explain some of the tensions present within the album. It also tracks with the meta-commentary on the values Clarkson sings about learning from her mother at a young age in the song “high road”; namely that “To become strong, you had to only / Cover your fears, don’t show you’re lonely / Put others first, before your own needs.” She lets us know that “it’s not all bad,” but also that she gets lonely and sad and feels broken.

As the song progresses, it sounds more and more like this stoic approach to life is wearing her down. Towards the end, she synthesizes lessons learned: “To become stronger, you have to listen / Keep it open, don’t try to hide it”; by the end of the song, Clarkson is over this nonsense: “I’m getting tired of playin’ these stupid games … I don’t need this.”

Listening to “me” through the lens of “high road” makes it nearly tolerable. “Me” may be the mask Clark presents to the world, but alongside this mask, she shows a self that is lonely and sad and feeling broken. If we are to believe Clarkson when she sings, “It’s just my ego and my pride / I live my life in disguise / And when I’m hurtin’, it’s incognito / So everybody thinks I’m a hero,” then one might read “me” as a kind of joke, an inward collapse that can only occur within the resting place that is God.

Alongside its songs, the album’s cover art evokes vulnerability, doubt, and even hints of collapse. The album cover presents Clarkson in a flowy, bohemian dress, statuesque, with arms open to the pain that love can deliver; yet, something about it is hesitant: her hands are cupped, as if someone has tried to pry her fingers out of fists that were formed in the heat of battle. She looks both concerned and in pain; her form is presented in triplicate, a sort of trinity of the self (“Just me, myself, and I”), but blurred, insinuating an internal dissolution.

This cover art aligns with themes from chemistry’s “lighthouse,” wherein Clarkson admits to the passive and sometimes destructive nature of attraction, singing: “Like a wave, you’re always / crashin’ into me.” She recognizes her own little control over the story that chemistry tells: this has happened, whether or not she wanted it to. This acknowledgement parallels the chaotic, give-and-take nature of life; it happens, and our place within it is very small. Like the lighthouse whose “light is burnin’ out,” “we are so ruined, and so loved, and in charge of so little” (to quote Anne Lamott).

As in “lighthouse,” there is a notably (Taylor) Swiftian vulnerability in chemistry’s “magic” that echoes praise and worship music. In “magic,” Clarkson proclaims her faith in this crashing-into-her love: “All my worry, all my doubt, I am layin’ at your feet,” while also considering and perhaps even questioning whether or not this love really happened. She describes the romance as “magic” but also “still so real”; in “rock hudson,” she sings that “it was real and it wasn’t.” These dialectics (real/not real) suggest the shell-shocked lyric threaded throughout Taylor Swift’s “All Too Well”: “Sacred prayer, I was there, I was there.” Swift sings “I was there” 25+ times, suggesting that she needs to hear it that many times in order to believe it. But she was there; something did happen (between her and that one dude), even if it’s now less tangible than a speck of dust.

At Mockingbird’s 2023 NYC conference, Esau McCauley articulated how:

trauma can shrink our field of vision so that we cannot see the evidence of God at work all around us. Trauma can cause us to relitigate our past so that all of our previous experiences of God were fake, and now all that is real are the problems in front of us.

This kind of litigation and re-litigation parallels Clarkson’s (and Swift’s) tellings of their love stories: “this thing happened, but did it? It did, though. It did.” In a bigger sense, God was here (in the form of Jesus), and then He left, but also He’s still here.

The deluxe version of the album includes a song called “i won’t give up.” In it, Clarkson articulates relinquishing the old relationship but hints at new possibilities, singing: “I see visions in my mind so close that I can feel them come alive” (whoa!) and repeats both “I won’t give up” and “I give it up” (more dialectics!). On her self-named talk show, Clarkson sings while casually strolling through the city, using her badge to swipe into Rockefeller Center, high-fiving and hugging coworkers (including Al Roker), and finally performing the remainder of the song to her live audience, where at least one very enthusiastic greeter is bopping along. Truly, how else are we to live in this kingdom-yet-to-come world besides by not giving up and also giving up (every damn day)?

With an ability to gather such disperse truths in her arms and hold them gently, as if they’re scattering children, I think Kelly Clarkson is going to be just fine.

subscribe to the Mockingbird newsletter

COMMENTS


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *