1. The Christian author Philip Yancey has always had a compelling way to talk about grace, particularly in its subversiveness to legalism. Judging by his recent memoir, it seems that this counter-cultural impulse reflects something of his life story. Ahead of the book’s release, Christianity Today published an excerpt where Yancey recounts his time at a Christian college — where Yancey learned of the difference between Christianity and religion, between grace and judgment. But to the dismay of administrators, Yancey learned this by being anything but a law-abiding citizen:
Shockingly, the college has hired a sociologist with a degree from Harvard. He assigns Erving Goffman’s book Asylums, a landmark study of what the author calls “total institutions.” Goffman suggests that institutions such as prisons, military academies, convents, insane asylums—and Bible colleges?—progressively condition their subjects so that in time the insiders habituate to their controlled setting. The ability to make a bed so tight that coins bounce off doesn’t help a recruit on the battlefield. It does, however, reinforce a military command structure: “I am in charge, and you must do what I say.”
As if to confirm my suspicions, in one of our private meetings the dean of men admits to me that he retains some petty rules simply to teach students to obey. Which gives me an idea for my sociology project.
I distribute a printed survey form to every male freshman and senior, asking such unscientific questions as “Which rule bothered you most on entering this school?” and “Has your attitude of rebellion against the school declined since you enrolled?” True to my hunch, the seniors accept, and even defend, rules and policies that freshmen think ridiculous.
When the dean finds a copy of my mimeographed survey in a trash can, once again I land on the faculty’s watch list. “This is an insurrection!” says the college president. “He can’t survey freshmen. They don’t know us!”—which was my point, exactly.
The project helps me separate the school’s subculture from the body of faith it so jealously guards. Perhaps I am resisting not God but people who speak for God. I’ve already learned to distrust my childhood churches’ views on race and politics. What else should I reject? A much harder question: What should I keep? […]
From the Bible I am learning about a God who has a soft spot for rebels, who empowers such people as the adulterer David, the cheater Jacob, the whiner Jeremiah, the traitor Peter, and the human-rights abuser Saul of Tarsus. A God whose Son makes prodigals the heroes of his stories.
2. It’s been amusing for me to read the ongoing reviews of Ted Lasso’s second season, which has not been as reliably well-received as the first. The show has lost its plot (or so it is said), pivoting from what made the first season so enjoyable. The focus on mental health may be laudable, but the magic of the first season is lost. To my mind, season two is meant to clarify misinterpretations of season one — that the show was never about boundless optimism, but kindness. Along these lines, Megan Garber’s comments on the show ring true:
Throughout American history, but definitely right now in influencer culture and wellness culture, there’s this ongoing debate about, “Can we be in charge of our own happiness? How do we actually find happiness? Is happiness something that can be bought? Is it something that can be willed into effect?” I’m reading this book right now, William Leach’s Land of Desire, about the history of consumerism in America (which I would really recommend). I mention it because it has a whole section on the mind-cure movement in early America, Norman Vincent Peale, the power of positive thinking.
And so much of our culture right now is based on the notion that you can cure your own mind. That if you want happiness enough, you can achieve it. And I think in some ways, Ted is such a faith-based person. And part of his faith in Season 2 transfers over from faith about the team’s ability to win and faith in other people to faith in his own ability to heal himself. And that’s a message that a lot of Americans are given. Whatever your circumstances, whatever the structural forces weighing down on you, ultimately it’s on you to fix yourself. And I think Ted embodies that in the second season.
And I think the show is arguing that you can’t do it alone, and it is actually kind of cruel to ask people to deal with whatever they’re dealing with on their own. It’s got to be a team effort.
For his part, Jason Sudeikis likened the second season to The Empire Strikes Back, so that’s at least on indication of what to expect for the season three.
3. In a remarkable transformation, the last 10 years has seen veganism (eating only plant-based products) quietly move from the butt of jokes on late night talk shows to becoming a fixture of mainstream culture. The impossible burger probably had something to do with that change; it’s hard to make fun of that one friend when the King of burgers has imputed righteousness to veganism. But that’s not to say that vegans themselves are happy with the newfound cultural acceptance.
Writing in the Washingonian, Nancy Scola details the ongoing in-fighting within veganism over issues of ideological purity. To many, cultural acceptance has come by way of watering down the message. At the heart of this debate is the impossible burger, which fulfills the letter of the law (do not eat meat) but perpetuates a preference for the taste of meat.
Riccio is assembling a mini-empire to feed diners who have spent the entirety of their vegan-eating lives pining for “chicken” that doesn’t chomp like rubber.
But here’s the thing: Amid all her success, she still can’t bring herself to identify as vegan. And there’s a whole tribe of plant-only diners who look at chefs like her and instead of seeing triumph—more people for the cause!—they see sellouts, people who cater to animal-eaters, even in fake form. “Vegans hate me,” Riccio says, and laughs. […]
As the vegan scene has blown up, so have all kinds of ideological factions and (sometimes amusing) stylistic clashes among its faithful. […]
For fun, I called PETA for its take on Vegan vs. Vegan, thinking the hard-line organization devoted to the ethical treatment of animals probably held a hard line on the issue. Nope. “Make it in the shape of a whole chicken or suckling pig, for all I care,” Ingrid Newkirk, president of the Dupont Circle–based group, told me. But the message was not exactly unified. Lisa Lange, the organization’s senior VP for communications, said, “If we’re making ‘turkey’ look like turkey, we’re perpetuating the idea that turkey are ours to eat, and they’re not.”
With vegan brands titled “Everlasting Life” it’s hard to not see the parallels between the veganism movement and Christianity; the hardline vegans in particular strike me as analogous to 4th century monasticism. But the existence of fissures within veganism well illustrates the tendency toward legalism for groups defined along purely ideological lines (religious or otherwise).
4. Writer Joseph Keegin had a complicated relationship with his father. Keegin would go years without speaking to his dad, an estrangement that stretched back into his teenage years. And then the call came that his dad was nearing the end of his struggle with heart disease. He would die five days later. An atheist studying philosophy at the time, Keegin embarked on a search for a way to “overcome our animosity and frustration toward one another.” As told in his recent article in Comment, Keegin suspected that forgiveness might be the key to not only come to terms with his rocky relationship, so he turned to books to find answers — first to Greek philosophy, then on to Buddhism, before finally stopping at Christianity.
The consensus among the Greeks, it seemed, is that ethical activity is grounded in care toward one’s own soul. If forgiveness is morally valuable, it is because anger gums up the gears of one’s own flourishing and distracts one from more noble pursuits, such as engaging in politics, grasping for honours, or achieving spiritual equanimity. One might express concern for another if their spiritual greatness matches one’s own, if both parties are equally worthy of honour and praise. But concern for the good of another in full knowledge of all their flaws—even in their wretchedness—is alien to the Greek moral imagination.
Keegin was even more disappointed with Buddhism, in which the “specificity and particularity of another person disappears altogether, subsumed into a system that one carefully maintains like a rock garden.” Buddhism implied that his estranged dad was merely the occasion of his anger — no different than the aggressive driver on the road.
Yet Keegin was apprehensive to point his the quest to understand forgiveness toward Christianity, which he believed was “too good to be true,” because it “papered over the real ugliness of the world with a happy message about hope and love.” Reading the Gospel of Luke, he found instead “a place where human reason — even at its greatest and most noble — had been unable to go.”
The ancient philosophers of Greece, Rome, and the East were not stupid: they were some of the smartest, most perceptive, and thoughtful people who have ever walked on this planet. Aristotle invented logic; Epicurus was one of the first thinkers to suspect that the things we encounter in experience are actually made up of much smaller fundamental particles linked together in various ways. They observed the world with a remarkable keenness of vision, and the conclusions they’ve arrived at represent truly heroic attempts at comprehending the nature of human life using our natural ability to reason. Their thinking is good: they are right that it is good to avoid being angry, and to treat your own soul with kindness and care. And yet for each and every one of them, the idea that we should love our enemies would have registered as self-evidently absurd. They might insist that we avoid having our souls poisoned by grudges, but the idea that we should love people who harm us would be ridiculous to them.
Here, Christ tells us to love our enemies; later, he shows us what it means. […] Hanging on the cross, in the process of being tortured and executed, Christ looks down onto the people responsible for his death and prays to God to forgive them. He is not ridding himself of anger to achieve spiritual tranquility; he is not trying to restore the karmic balance of the universe; he is not trying to showcase his own virtue. His concern, in the midst of his execution, is for the good of those who have wronged him. And it is entirely for their sake that he utters his prayer of forgiveness.
5. In humor this week, the New Yorker has “Ugh, Dating Is So Hard These Days When You’re an Insufferable Person with a Bland Personality.” And after the all the Facebook bad press this week, McSweeney’s posted a new job advertisement for Facebook’s Apologies team, which sounds like the perfect gig for anyone well versed in self-justification.
But by far my favorite this week dives head first into the discomfort we might feel ever Sunday morning. No, it’s not about going to a legalistic church, but the weekly iPhone screen time report (if you haven’t disabled the app judgment, that is): “Explaining My Daily Screen-Time Average to the Spirit of My Great-Great-Grandmother.”
What exactly am I staring at for five hours and twenty-one minutes each day? Anything I want, really. Technology has advanced in such incredible ways that the whole library of human knowledge is accessible to me from my phone. All the greatest works of art and literature and—
Well, no, I’m usually not looking at any of those things. Uh, I guess I mostly use it to look up where I know an actor from or to view snapshots of the daily lives of people I haven’t spoken to in years […]
O.K., I can see how you may think that this isn’t a healthy or productive use of my time, and that it’s altering the wiring of my brain until all that’s left is a mush, reminiscent of the one your mother used to serve every Friday night. But what’s the alternative — not reaching for my phone every idle instant? Being alone with my thoughts and trying to find meaning in an increasingly chaotic and dire world? No thanks! I’ll take mush brains, please.
And I know what I’ll be watching this weekend:
6. Finally, in the latest issue of The Lamp, Tomás Díaz offered a phenomenal reflection his life with disability. To him, weakness is “an emptiness which cries for something more.” Díaz was born with spinal muscular atrophy, requiring a wheelchair since the age of seven. Throughout his life, his disability has been supported by those whose lives were invited to transform with him in it. But not everyone has been so understanding or accommodating. For Díaz, a single episode of childhood bullying at the hands of “Tony” transformed his understanding of life (and faith):
From this point on I also found that strength became something of an abstraction, a thing out there, and not in here. Yes, teachers always talked about finding your so-called “inner strength,” of gaining independence. This always seemed patronizing, a request to ignore one’s weakness and to play make-believe, a purposeful blindness to the quarterback’s deep pass, the dancer’s infectious jive, the runner’s sublime endurance. If this was strength I was very weak indeed. […]
There are still Tonys out in the world, grown up to all appearances. These are men and women who mindlessly see the beauty of physical strength, of a life devoted to it, and seek to laud it by looking down on the weak. You know the type: the right-wing gym devotees, the Bronze Age mindset guys, the ones posting on social media about “gains” and protein and soyboys. It certainly has its appeal. And it’s also funny.
Besides, there is a kernel of truth to it. The strength of the body, of a life of discipline and the attainment of might, is a good thing. It is even beautiful. But its beauty is not in self-aggrandizement. It is in the capacity to empty itself. This is the glory of strength, in shining forth in service to weakness.
This is Christ in His resurrection. There, in His once broken but now luminous body, we see manifest the whole plentitude of power. Yes, we are drawn to adore this perfect vision of strength, a might that has trampled death. But to halt there is to misunderstand the full extent of that glory. For the Lord, at the apex of creation, and from the very heart of divinity, risen and ascended, still comes down into weakness: no longer His own, but ours, a humiliating descent, hidden in the taste of bread and wine and exercised by the hands of fallible men. By the Spirit, he enters and sustains the most wretched among us, lifting us by gentle and often painful steps to Himself. This is a stumbling block to all the Tonys of the world. Such power, such strength, such might is only made perfect by weakness. Pour forth, says Christ, what my Father has lavished upon you, upon us, and all glory will be had.
In my weakness, with atrophied limbs and a sometimes faltering spirit, I’ve been privileged to see this truth made manifest. I have been blessed to be the empty vessel for stronger men to shine forth their glory. That they do so in all humility only makes their actions more beautiful. For this reason I have learned (a goodly bit of the time anyway) to love my weakness, a weakness to which another might respond, looking within himself and seeing anew the power he has been given and the possibility that it can be perfected.
Strays:
- Ordinary People: the line between the everyday and the exceptional.
- Featured image via: The holy simplicity of artist John August Swanson.
- Think Christian has a new (free) book on pop music and the psalms.
- What American Christians Hear at Church.







Riccio is assembling a mini-empire to feed diners who have spent the entirety of their vegan-eating lives pining for “chicken” that doesn’t chomp like rubber.
