Another Week Ends

Crying at Movies, Squirming Higher Ed, Iatrogenic Therapies, Family Apps, and Sisyfitness

Bryan Jarrell / 5.24.24

1. Let’s check in with higher ed. Graduation season continues, as does news coverage of student protests over the Israel and Palestine war interrupting these graduation ceremonies. Eliot A. Cohen writes in the Atlantic about the various ways that universities across the country have been handling this season of protest, and argues that the institutional instinct to take a moral stance on the political matters of the day doesn’t align with the institution’s purpose:

Presumably, students come to a university for an education, which implies that they need to be educated, which means that they are not, in fact, ready to make the deeper judgments on which society depends. They are high on passion, and, as interviewers have found, many of them are extraordinarily ignorant about the causes for which they are demonstrating.

As for faculty, reading the novels of David Lodge and Julie Schumacher — not to mention viewing Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf? — would confirm the view that I have come to after 40 years in departmental meetings, that one should not expect too much by way of prudence and profound moral and political judgment from them, either. There are sterling characters among the professoriate — heroic, self-sacrificing, and wise. There are a great many more who are simply passionately dedicated to a subject, be it broad or arcane, and just want to teach and research it and otherwise be left in peace. But in addition, there are the garden-variety intriguers, backstabbers, prima donnas, and bullies. There are also quite a few adulterers, predators, egomaniacs, and borderline swindlers, and even a sociopath or two. Some professors are experienced in the ways of the world; most of them are not, having viewed it with all the blessed autonomy and freedom from the constraints of politics or war that universities appropriately provide. They have no special qualification for the role of society’s conscience.

The university’s real missions are noble: education, particularly of the young, and the pursuit of the truth. The people engaged in that mission may or may not be the finest characters in the world, or have the best moral or political judgment, but the missions are of the highest importance. It is the business of academic leaders to sustain their institution’s commitment to those missions, and nothing more. They have neither the moral standing nor the credibility in wider society for exceeding that mandate, or doing anything other than creating an optimal environment for learning and research, upholding the rules, and stewarding the institution’s finances.

The leaders of universities do not exist to pass judgment on politics, or twist their endowments into moralistic knots, or attempt to shape the course of American foreign policy. As individuals, they (and students, faculty, and administrators) may have something useful to say about politics and every right to do so. In their official roles, they should have none.

This reflection struck me for two reasons, one being a criticism and the other being a caution. The criticism I have is that Cohen’s vision of higher ed as “amoral” in its pursuit of truth is not a time tested concept. Pre-enlightenment western understandings of truth, whether it’s the Greek philosophers or Christian scholastics, linked truth together with goodness and beauty. I’m not so sure that a university has the luxury of attempting its work without some measure of moral concern. Cohen’s greater point, however, stands: grandiose commitments to the cause du jour undermine the greater truths that the university’s ethos is yoked to. For the church, Cohen’s point is a great caution, a reminder to not jeopardize our role as ambassadors for a heavenly kingdom with the temporal moral urgencies of our time. Higher ed has the pursuit of truth to attend to, and the church has its own mission to proclaim the Christian gospel. Why risk reputation and failure by tarrying in lesser matters unless we think those goals are no longer worth achieving?

2. The word of the week this week is “iatrogenic.” It’s a medical term used to describe harm and illness that are the results of a medical treatment. Examples include developing an infection after a surgery because a wound wasn’t properly closed, an allergic rash from a nurse’s latex gloves, or a negative side effect of a new drug prescription. The scope of the word is broad, but the concept is simple: people have an iatrogenic condition when their harm is experienced as a result of a medical treatment.

The practices of therapy and counseling have been recently scrutinized because of this concept of iatrogenic harm. This is true especially for children’s therapy. Over in the New Atlantis, Leah Libresco Sargeant reviews a new book by Abigail Shrier, who suggests that it’s these very iatrogenic concerns that are contributing to the global crisis of youth mental health.

When Shrier signs up for a “wellness tracker” intended for teens age sixteen and up, the basic check-in offered by the app has a number of negatively flavored questions for the user to meditate on and rate on a scale:

“How worried do you feel right now?”

“How down do you feel right now?”

“How often do you feel left out?”

“How sad do you feel right now?” […]

For a child or an adult, repeatedly drawing one’s attention back to feelings of discomfort can create a negative feedback loop, over-sensitizing oneself to irritations that might have otherwise passed unnoticed. Getting bogged down in anxious self-examination can start to feel like making progress, amassing more and more information to pore over with a therapist or another therapeutically-minded friend. What might have been a brief, passing unhappiness or awkwardness is probed urgently for what wound or weakness it might reveal. These excavations work with the assumption that we are largely unknown to ourselves. Like an astronomer observing a black hole by tracking the subtle wobble of surrounding stars, doing the work means being alert to subtle signals of the hidden ordering of one’s internal universe. […]

The question of the extent to which our feelings are us is a complicated one, and not solely the province of psychologists. Shrier is focused on present-day excesses, but looking beyond therapeutic practice offers some alternatives to either excessive solicitude or toughing it out. Eastern Orthodoxy gives the name logismos to what a therapist might call an intrusive thought. In The Mountain of Silence, a monk on Mount Athos in Greece tells author Kyriacos C. Markides that “a logismos does not necessarily emanate from within [a person], but is directed toward them from the outside.” Reflecting on one’s thoughts is a process of judgment, not just self-discovery. Taking responsibility to judge our thoughts implies there are parts of ourselves that we prune, that we are aiming to grow in a particular direction. That’s easier for a monk to say than a therapist.

By undergoing a psychotherapeutic treatment that trains us to be hyper-focused on our negative emotions, we become so attuned to them that they overwhelm us. The author’s point is that this is especially true with kids and adolescents, whose negativity barometer isn’t calibrated to understand the difference between an emotional speed bump and a pothole. This is the iatrogenic consequence of therapy, one that should be a consideration as people decide whether to engage with the treatment. (See also: Philippians 4:8-9 for St. Paul’s take on the matter).

For more on this iatrogenic concept check out Scott Alexander’s review of The Others Within Us, a book that outlines the complexity of treating patients who might actually be possessed by demonic forces. Come for the story of the missionary monk in China that became an unwitting exorcist, stay for the fascinating outline of a secular exorcism. Also, for more on the challenge of therapy concepts leaking out of the medical world and into everyday life, there’s Be Quick to Listen, Slow to ‘Therapy Speak’ over at Christianity Today.

3. No need to ask you “how worried do you feel right now?,” but I will ask, “what’s the most recent movie that made you cry?” Heather Havrilesky makes the case that Hollywood needs to bring back tear-jerker movies, lamenting how the genre has been relegated to Hallmark Christmas specials and b-movies recommendations nobody watches on streaming platforms. A good communal cry, she argues, would do us a lot of good.

Tear-jerkers can look a little manipulative, or even cartoonish, in retrospect. Here is a dying woman saying goodbye to her young sons! Here is a father running through the streets of New York carrying his injured child to the hospital! Here is Bette Midler singing “Did you ever know that you’re my hero?” to her terminally ill best friend! But prestige tear-jerkers served an essential cultural purpose: They were a valuable ritual of catharsis that audiences could participate in together. If you’ve seen any one of these movies, you might feel emotional just recalling it, which is proof of their enduring power. Sobbing together is something we’ve forgotten how to do — and something we badly need to rediscover. We need more chances to show our humanity to one another in public. We need to learn how to reassure one another that we are all sensitive beings who are at risk of feeling much more than we can tolerate. We could all use a good cry right now, together, in real life, in real time. […]

It’s easy to see why audiences may be hesitant to go to a communal space to watch slow, tragic stories about human suffering. Real sadness is everywhere, and we digest it on our own now, alone, with our phones, in silence. Maybe that’s the real reason prestige tear-jerkers have gone extinct: We confront despair so rapidly and constantly now that we’ve learned to dismiss sadness and push it out of sight and to deride it in others, no matter how sincere it might be. We’ve forgotten how to feel anything collectively besides outrage. Look no further than the Covid-19 pandemic: Over a million Americans died in an experience that touched us all, and yet there is still no permanent national Covid memorial. There’s little acknowledgment of a need for closure, let alone a move to provide it.

4. Call me a sleep-needy father of preschoolers, but the last time I cried watching anything was that darn Bluey special last month. Thankfully, Zillow threw us a bone with this cheeky advert to help us parents get a bit of perspective. Also in humor this week, call me a millennial, but the Hard Times got a laugh from me with “Life Imitates Art: This Blink-182 Fan is Legitimately Struggling to Remember His Age.” The Onion reports that “Woman Doesn’t Appreciate Being Told To Chill Out By Reggae Song.” See also Sisyfitness (below).

5. Erin Griffith asks the million dollar question over at the New York Times: “Some couples are using professional project-management software to maintain their relationships. Why does it bother other people?” Why indeed — I know that I bristle at the idea that we need a family Slack channel, or some other family specific productivity app designed to make life easier. But if these tools are designed to make my life easier, and to give me more free time in these insanely busy preschooler-parent years, why am I so averse to it? Griffith observes:

Ben Lang didn’t expect to get so much hate just for being organized. For the past three years, he and his wife, Karen-Lynn Amouyal, have been using Notion, a popular software tool, to optimize their household and relationship. His version of the tool, commonly used by businesses to manage complex projects, functions like a souped-up Google Doc, with sections for a grocery list, to-do lists and details of upcoming trips.

More unusual is a section Mr. Lang, a venture capital investor who previously worked at Notion, created about principles (“what’s important to us as a couple”). Another section, called “Learnings,” outlines things the couple have discovered about each other, such as their love languages and Myers-Briggs test results. There’s a list of friends they want to set up on dates. They also maintain a log of memories from their date nights. Mr. Lang, 30, was so proud of the creation that last month, he started promoting a template of the setup to others. “My wife and I use Notion religiously to manage our day-to-day life,” he wrote on X. “I turned this into a template, let me know if you’d like to see it!”

The internet responded with a venomous outrage. […]

But his approach isn’t entirely unusual, especially among people who work in the tech industry and want to manage their personal lives the same way they manage their professional lives. For a class of young workers, it’s only rational to apply the tools of the corporate world to their relationships and families. Businesses have goals and systems for achieving them, the thinking goes. They get things done. […]

Relationships are work, but no one wants to admit it. But this particular flavor of life hacking often causes observers to collectively recoil. It threatens to take the romance and spontaneity out of life, in their view. It feels cold. “There is a phenomenon whereby the more you try to manage your life, the more you risk squeezing the vibrancy out of it,” said Oliver Burkeman, author of “Four Thousand Weeks: Time Management for Mortals.” And yet, the crushing overwhelm of modern life, with daily to-do lists and schedules and notifications and digital logistics can feel so never-ending that any solution offering to optimize even the tiniest task — or most meaningful relationship — looks like a lifeline worth grasping for.

Silicon Valley’s incessant need to optimize everything, what Jacques Ellul famously called “technique,” has increased the pace of life for all people, whether they can keep up or not. And so, to answer Griffith’s question, it’s disingenuous for company managers who increased our pace of life to suggest that the answer is more apps, more spreadsheets, and better optimization. It’s a very San Francisco idea to suggest that we solve the problems caused by technology with … more technology. The backlash against family management style apps and the problems they “solve” come from a deeply spiritual place, a firm “no” to a culture of exhaustion and performance that sees family life as a means to worldly success and not as an end in and of itself. (See also Sarah Condon’s reflection on May-Cember and the obligations that come with the end of the school year. I bet whosever idea it was to have an end-of-year dress up spirit week has a household management app.)

6. In the New York Review of Books, Peter Brown reviews Peter Heather’s new book Christendom: The Triumph of a Religion, AD 300-1300. The review is mostly positive, especially in his appreciation of how little actually changed when Constantine because a Christian, but Brown concludes with a bit of Pentecost verve, wishing that historians would take genuine belief in the faith as a historically relevant force, and give it the transformative credit it deserves. (There’s an excellent historiography of St. Patrick in this article well worth your time, too, but it’s too long to reprint here).

Let me make a suggestion: modern historiography of the expansion of the early Church seems to have left little room for the Holy Ghost. Don’t get me wrong: I do not speak as a theologian but as a historian. We should remember that the people we study lived in a world crowded with invisible beings. Some of these beings were demons driven by chill malevolence. We hear much about them in literature and in contemporary belief. But humans could also be touched by the warm presence of benevolent spirits, seen as ever ready to protect and to inspire individuals. We should not forget that even the classical Muses, outdated though they might appear, continued to be surrounded by a numinous aura. When the senator and poet Paulinus of Nola announced to Ausonius in the late fourth century that he had been converted to Christianity, it was enough for him to explain to his old mentor that he had found that the mighty wind of Christ blew into his heart with greater warmth than did the plump classical ladies still displayed on innumerable works of late Roman art.

A language of inspiration, based on belief in the proximity of nurturing powers, served to explain unusual actions, new departures, and unprecedented acts of creativity. Praying in church around 270, Anthony, a comfortable Egyptian farmer, was inspired by the words of Christ in a Gospel: “If you would be perfect, go, sell what you have and give to the poor” (Matthew 19:21). This inspiration came to him in a manner described in a contemporary Syriac version of his Life: he prayed “that a thought of righteousness might rise up in his heart.” Some divine power had bubbled up within him.

And hearts kept bubbling in this way all over Europe and the Middle East. Such experiences were by no means random and marginal. Major cultural enterprises got underway because they were conceived of as driven by the Holy Ghost. Mesrop Mashtots invented the Armenian alphabet in the fifth century in order to translate the Bible. He was said to have had a vision of this alphabet being written on hard stone by the hand of God “as clearly as if on a field of snow.” In 680, in Whitby on the Yorkshire coast, Caedmon, a humble equerry, was inspired by an angel to sing a short hymn of praise in a high Saxon speech previously limited to elite warriors. […]

There is room in the history of Christendom both for those who “were probably still there … primarily for the beer” and for those who were “filled with new wine” (Acts 2:13), with unpredictable results, such as still amaze and delight the historian of every aspect of the triumph of a religion.

7. A short clip from poet Christian Wiman, excerpted from an interview over at the Hedgehog Review, about noble ambition. In response to a moderator’s question about the drive that keeps him writing, Wiman responds:

You mentioned Milton, Abram. He said, “Fame is the spur that the clear spirit doth raise / (That last infirmity of noble mind) / To scorn delights and live laborious days.” So it is a clear spirit in that poem. He thinks of fame as a kind of noble ambition. But it is also an infirmity — the last infirmity of a noble mind. It’s both. I always wanted for the dead to make a place for me. It’s not necessarily projecting forward. Instead, I want to be recognized by the dead. I want Yeats and Eliot and Milton to scoot over a little bit on the bench and make a place for me. And that seems okay. I mean, it’s good to have a noble ambition. It’s always seemed to me the greatest compliment for a poet is if someone would come up to you and have your poem memorized but not know who you were — not know who wrote it. They just had the poem itself. That seems to me the greatest honor. And freedom. Because the poem has done it. You’re not involved. You’re gone. So I think there’s always this tug between the ambition for the work and the need for humility in the world. But it’s ambition for the work. The kind of ambition that wants to win the Pulitzer Prize — that is not a noble ambition. We all have it, but it’s not noble. That’s more than an infirmity. That’ll kill you. Because you’re feeding a hunger that is not finally able to be filled. You get one thing, and you want the next. It’s just endless.

8. The last word this week goes to Wesley Hill, whose insights on the doubts of the apostles at the end of Matthew’s gospel help clarify the importance of Pentecost and offers good news for those who doubt today:

I grew up hearing the story of Easter from before I knew how to talk, but I only noticed Matthew 28:16-17 when I was a teenager: “Now [after Jesus’ resurrection] the eleven disciples went to Galilee, to the mountain to which Jesus had directed them. And when they saw him they worshiped him; but some doubted” (RSV). What did it mean, I wondered with a sense of shock and scandal, that some of Jesus’ followers who saw with their own eyes that he was alive … doubted? […]

If we look more carefully at Matthew’s Greek text, however, the meaning of the disciples’ doubt becomes less clear. The RSV passage makes it sound as if the disciples are divided into two groups: those who worshiped Jesus, and those (others) who doubted. But, as Walter Moberly points out in The Bible, Theology, and Faith, the Greek syntax does not favor this interpretation. It’s likelier that the subject of the two verbs — worshiped and doubted — is the same group and that it is the entire company of those who meet Jesus on the mountain. This explains why the updated edition of the NRSV differs from the RSV: “When they saw him, they worshiped him, but they doubted.” All those who worshiped also doubted, and vice versa.

Moberly proposes one further tweak, though. He asks whether doubted is the best way to render the verb distazo in English, since in the one other place in Matthew’s Gospel where it appears (14:31), it suggests a certain flailing or uncertainty, rather than skepticism. So Moberly translates 28:17: “when [the disciples] saw [Jesus] they reverently prostrated themselves. But they were hesitant.”

But why would the disciples, in the presence of the risen Christ, be hesitant or uncertain? Centuries of Christian tradition have blunted our ability to appreciate the sheer strangeness and shock of one faithful Jew being raised from the dead in advance of the hoped-for general resurrection of all the dead at the culmination of history. Many of Jesus’ contemporaries, schooled in the prophecies of Isaiah and Daniel, were eagerly anticipating the latter; none were expecting the former. And so the earliest witnesses of the risen Jesus were confused about what it should mean for them, what it obliged them to say or do. Should they go back to their fishing and hunker down in Galilee for a few more weeks or months (surely not years?) until Jesus returned unambiguously to establish his kingship? Or … what, exactly? Given the bizarreness of Easter morning, just what was the appropriate response?

Maybe this hesitation can help us better understand the assurance, joy, and boldness that came with the end of Jesus’ resurrection appearances and the arrival of the Spirit on the day of Pentecost. If seeing Jesus alive brought a kind of happy but hesitant hope, it was what happened next that solidified the disciples’ faith and galvanized their missionary proclamation. With the presence of the Spirit, it now became unmistakably clear that Jesus had been raised and exalted not for some arcane purpose but precisely so that he could be present in a newly empowering, comforting way.

Strays:

And finally, our semi-annual appeal letter should be arriving over the weekend! If you would like to be on our mailing list (or if you’ve recently moved) fill out this form here. To support Mbird and work we do, CLICK HERE.

subscribe to the Mockingbird newsletter

COMMENTS


2 responses to “May 18-24”

  1. Tom Huddle says:

    On Cohen and universities; i dont think from what he said you need conclude that his vision of academia is of pursuit of truth in an “amoral” fashion. Of course academic practices are hemmed in and suffused with moral constraints and ideals of all sorts. The important point is to maintain a distinction between academics and (partisan) politics. Academics should focus on understanding the world, not (while wearing their academic hats) on changing it.

  2. DLE says:

    “Virtue” is the missing piece in the higher ed puzzle. Universities once made developing virtuous students their mission. Now, if the product of four years of contemporary academics is any indicator, it seems as if universities exist instead to burn all virtue out of their students—and they’ve been damningly successful.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *