Another Week Ends

The IKEA Effect, Ineffective Altruism, Victorian Manners, Bonhoeffer’s Secret, and Rwandan Forgiveness

Bryan Jarrell / 4.12.24

1. Wired gets the first nod this week with its criticism of the moral foundations behind Effective Altruism. The EA movement promised to change the world by directing charitable giving to organizations that did the most good, promising to use every dollar donated in the most efficient manner. Figureheads would run the numbers and outline how mosquito nets or deworming pills or drilling wells would do the most good in alleviating poverty and illness to save lives, and work to funnel funding in that direction. The movement has been tarnished by crypto-mogul Sam Bankman-Fried’s recent jail sentence — SBF was the most visible and vocal proponent and sponsor of the movement. Leif Wenar, the Stanford professor writing for Wired, argues that the problems with EA are exponentially more challenging than the imprisonment of its chief public advocate:

“Say you had a million dollars,” I asked when they’d started eating. “Which charity would you give it to?” They looked at me. “No, really,” I said, “which charity saves the most lives?”

“None of them,” said a young Australian woman to laughter. Out came story after story of the daily frustrations of their jobs. Corrupt local officials, clueless charity bosses, the daily grind of cajoling poor people to try something new without pissing them off. By the time we got to dessert, these good people, devoting their young lives to poverty relief, were talking about lying in bed forlorn some nights, hoping their projects were doing more good than harm. That was a shock. And, I’m embarrassed to say, a deeper shock came when I left Bali’s beaches to drive to the poorer parts of the island. That shock was the simple revelation of the reality of the people there. The Balinese I met seemed at least as upright and resourceful as the folks I knew back home; their daily lives were certainly more challenging. Glimpsing the world through the eyes of these villagers, and the immense distance between us, crashed through the games in my mind.

Wenar goes on to articulate how impossible it is to calculate the impact of a given intervention in a community, how interventions always include a butterfly-effect style impact on local economic and political realities, and how much of the statistical work undergirding EA’s decisions are disingenuous in their formulation. It turns out free mosquito nets, for example, make fantastic fishing nets, and many locals stopped using them for sleep and used them in the local creek. So not only do nets not solve the problem of malaria outright, but they also devastate fragile local ecosystems with overfishing. EA advocates happily tell you how much good a donation can do, but they avoid the hard truth that a donation can also do harm.

The other side of EA that Wernar attacks is the declaration of righteousness that EA provides to givers. When sites like GiveWell say that “$840 will guarantee that a life is saved,” Tech moguls and San Francisco billionaires, by a few clicks and the donation of a small portion of their wealth, can claim to be heroes from their generous giving, placing themselves along the firemen and superheroes they admired from their childhood.

And then there’s MacAskill’s philosophy of how to give credit, which is a big part of how he persuades people to give to EA charities. The measure of what you achieve, MacAskill writes, is the difference you make in the world: “the difference between what happens as a result of your actions and what would have happened anyway.” If you donate enough money to a charity that gives out insecticide-treated bed nets, MacAskill says, you will “save the life” of someone who otherwise would have died of malaria — just as surely as if you ran into a burning building and dragged a young child to safety.

But let’s picture that person you’ve supposedly rescued from death in MacAskill’s account — say it’s a young Malawian boy. Do you really deserve all the credit for “saving his life”? Didn’t the people who first developed the bed nets also “make a difference” in preventing his malaria? More importantly, what about his mother? She chose to trust the aid workers and use the net they handed to her, which not all parents do. Doesn’t her agency matter — doesn’t her choice to use the net “make a difference” in what happens to her child? Wouldn’t it in fact be more accurate for MacAskill to say that your donation offers this mother the opportunity to “save the life” of her own child?

Which is to say, effective altruism does not have a magic bypass or silver bullet for the same struggles that every single charity or NGO has had for generations. We should, perhaps, be weary when anyone claims such a distinctive leg up solving life’s messiest problems.

2. Fewer things have calmed my anxiety about the AI apocalypse than Amanda Montell’s reflection on crafting in her newly released book The Age of Magical Overthinking: Notes on Modern Irrationality. Marie Claire posted a chapter from the book on their website this week, and its playful appreciation for mediocre furniture flipping was a surprising and hopeful balm in a tech-saturated world. Can the Ikea Effect be the Achilles heel of a future dominated by software generated art and music?

Of all our projects, my favorite flip began as a dusty seashell lamp the color of mucus. Racheli and I found it for $10 at a neighborhood Goodwill and decided to take a risk. Decor in the style of 1980s Miami was enjoying a wacky revival, so we seized the moment by painting the lamp a shade of atrocious Hubba-Bubba-Bubble-Tape pink. “This thing is fugly. I feel bad selling it,” said Racheli. Before the flip, we’d mentally priced the lamp at $20, but the moment we placed our grubby little paws on it, some primal ghost took over. By the time the final pink paint coat dried, we concluded that with the right viral TikTok, the lamp could sell for hundreds. Let me reiterate, this object was grotesque. It looked like SpongeBob SquarePants’s pet snail, Gary. Thirty minutes prior, we saw that plainly. Now, we were listing it on the internet for the average price of a bottle of Veuve Clicquot. […]

Our lamp sold above asking price to a shiny-haired college student within an hour of posting. But it was never about the money. It was about that feeling. Finally, I grasped what that therapist meant. Nothing satisfies the spirit quite like building something yourself, or at least helping to. At the same time, nothing had ever warped my perception of “value” with such efficiency. What is it about a human hand?

Like the sunk cost fallacy, the IKEA effect is at its core another effort justification bias. How we love to defend our most expensive, time-consuming, irreversible choices. The ironic link between a task’s arduousness or permanence and our eagerness to rationalize it is why, when faced with a heavy decision — like whether or not to attend grad school or have another kid — psychologists caution against asking the advice of someone who just did it themselves. If a person endures involuntary pain on their path toward achievement (say, if they get a paper cut while folding origami, or are forced to finish out a prison sentence), that won’t make them appreciate the end result any more. But if they willingly endure suffering (if they opt to get the paper cut, or throw a wedding the price of a down payment), that paper crane will start to look like it’s made of porcelain.

In 1962, Sylvia Plath suggested a critique of the exceptionalist attitude that society had, just then, reached an unprecedented point of inhumanity. In a short essay titled “Context,” Plath problematized what she called “headline poetry”— choosing to reference the era’s major political conflicts (Hiroshima, the Cold War) so directly and sensationally in poems, as if the mid-twentieth century was sure to go down as the most worrying time in history and should be immortalized as such. Plath challenged readers to widen their lens. “For me,” she contended, “the real issues of our time are the issues of every time — the hurt and wonder of loving; making in all its forms — children, loaves of bread, paintings, buildings; and the conservation of life of all people in all places, the jeopardizing of which no abstract doubletalk of ‘peace’ or ‘implacable foes’ can excuse.” It is perhaps no coincidence that Plath wrote this essay the same year she began keeping bees, a craft which inspired many of her most iconic poems. Love, survival, creation by hand. Technology changes faster than the lifespan of a honeybee, but we are the hive.

Montell’s insight regarding the Ikea Effect is that, maybe, it isn’t all that bad to take pride and put value in work we have done ourselves, even if it isn’t computer generated perfection. Beyond this, as the Sylvia Plath quote outlines, the future of art and music may actually belong to those who can create it without the aid of AI. The authenticity of the thing made with hands, the self-justification it provides, these are a part of the human endeavor. It may sound like a risk for the religious types, whose justification is to come by faith alone and not the work of our hands. Instead, if we understand the Easter event to be that of voluntarily and willingly endured suffering, we may find that God himself is very much into love, survival, and creation, and we are simply thinking his thoughts (or flipping his furniture) after him.

3. Richard Beck continues the conversation about the right flower needing the right soil. Over at his Experimental Theology substack, Beck continues to wrestle with the faith as a “post-progressive” Christian, someone who has deconstructed their faith, but also done the hard work of building something back up in its place. Bonhoeffer was a big part of that journey for Beck, and earlier this week, Beck reflected on nearly fifteen years of interacting with the German theologian’s vision of a religionless (i.e. not a country club), others-focused church. The aspect of Bonhoeffer’s work that Beck has now come to appreciate, the missing piece from his past interactions with Bonhoeffer, was that the outward focused church he longed to see needed a cruciform, grace-centered core to sustain it.

I think those who want to reduce Bonhoeffer’s religionless Christianity to ethical social justice action in the world miss the radical Christological vision of “being there” for others, the cruciform nature of this lifestyle and its associated cost. Missing this cruciformity, they overlook all that is necessary to make a lifetime of self-donation sustainable, joyful, and hopeful. Back in 2010, when I first wrote this series, as a deconstructing, progressive, social justice Christian, I thrilled to how Bonhoeffer’s letters and papers described a church that existed for others. This remains my vision. And yet, fourteen years later, I’m increasingly aware of how our life together in the church, as we celebrate the mystery of Christ’s death and resurrection, makes our radical availability to the world joy-filled and hopeful and, therefore, sustainable.

And finally, looking back at this series here in 2024, I would also observe that all is not ethics. Since 2010, and largely due to my prison work, I have rediscovered grace […]

One of the problems I discern in the progressive Christian turn against penal substitutionary atonement is the eclipse of grace, reducing the cross to ethics. To be clear, I share concerns with certain expressions of penal substitutionary atonement. But when you work with a prison population you come to see, first-hand, the transformative power of forgiveness and grace. A Christianity that is reduced to ethical action in the world misses the gospel of grace. Your shame has been overcome. Your guilt undone. While we were yet sinners, Christ died for us. God does not treat us as our sins deserve. As far as the east is from the west, so far has God removed our transgressions from us. Nothing can separate you from the love of God. You have been washed in the blood of the Lamb. By his wounds you have been healed.

Beyond ethics, this too is the gospel. And I’ve come to believe that our “being there” for others means inviting a soul sick world into this grace.

It’s worth noting that Wernar’s rejection of EA and Beck’s affirmation of a theology of the cross both come after personal, individual experiences of working with the poor, whether that’s Wernar’s time in Bali or Beck’s work in prison ministry.

4. In humor this week, the Hard Times got vocal laughs with “Unsuccessful Lullaby Composer Embarrassed Most of Audience Is Awake,” and “Bonnie Tyler Projected To Earn $1.47 Off “Total Eclipse Of The Heart” Spotify Streams During Solar Eclipse.” The Onion offers “Residents Establish More Exclusive Gated Community Within First.” And McSweeneys has some fun at the expense of everyone’s favorite justice-warrior billionaire in their, “I Am Batman, And I Will Restore Order to Gotham by Pulverizing a Man Robbing a Convenience Store to Feed His Starving Family“:

The people of Gotham need a benevolent protector. And who better to protect the poverty-stricken working class than me, an eccentric billionaire who inherited his entire fortune? Ignore the fact that it is impossible to accumulate this much wealth without ruthlessly exploiting poor and working-class people. Right now, this city needs hope. They need a hero. They need someone who will work with the police to hunt down and pulverize each and every nonviolent drug offender within an inch of their life.

Sometimes, after a long night of fighting crime, I ask myself if the modes of exploitation were actually designed to keep impoverished families at a severe disadvantage in modern society. But then I remember the message etched on my billionaire father’s grave: “ANYONE WHO COMMITS ANY CRIME IS INHERENTLY EVIL,” and I know it is my responsibility to discharge military-grade stun batons on any jaywalker who has grown up with the odds stacked against them.

5. I learned this week that the famed Clampham Sect, the loose alliance of evangelical writers, clergy, politicians, and thinkers who worked to end the slave trade in Britain, was also a key player in the development of Victorian era morality. Over at the Hedgehog Review, James C. Rahn outlines how the group’s famed opposition to slavery was a part of a greater vision for social reform. As the industrial revolution transformed Britain’s work, family, and spiritual landscape, the Clampham group also worked to promote Sunday schools, champion safe working conditions in factories, limit alcohol consumption, animal welfare, and restrictions on capital punishment. Two generations later, this austere vision for what William Wilberforce called a “reformation of manners” would become the bedrock of Victorian English culture, for better and for worse.

Whether or not one shares the impression of many of their English contemporaries that they were sanctimonious do-gooders, the Claphamites unquestionably launched a revolution in manners that shaped what we have come to know as Victorian morality. The virtues advanced by the Claphamites, both by example and precept (the latter, for example, in the writings of Hannah More, which had a direct influence on the formation of the young Victoria before she became queen), were not “exalted or heroic” ones, as the historian Gertrude Himmelfarb rightly observed. “Hard work, sobriety, frugality, foresight — these were modest, mundane virtues, even lowly virtues,” Himmelfarb elaborated. “But they were virtues within the capacity of everyone; they did not assume any special breeding, or status, or talent, or valor, or grace — or even money. They were common virtues within the reach of common people.” By holding the working poor to the same standards to which they held themselves, the Claphamites contributed, modestly yet significantly, to both the democratization and liberalization of Victorian society. “The ethos of Clapham,” wrote Stephen Tomkins, a Wilberforce biographer, “became the spirit of the age.”

So far so good — a social commitment to hard work, sobriety, frugality, and foresight is generally good and achievable for all people. The problem, outlines Rahn, is that it didn’t stick.

Yet for all the Claphamites’ bold efforts at broader societal change, any revivification of authentic moral culture capable of reproducing itself ultimately fell short. Even by the last decades of the nineteenth century, the often austere moral vitalism of Christian pietism had devolved into what many saw as the suffocating moralism of the Victorian Age.

There are many reasons why the Wilberforce movement experienced immediate success but ultimate failure. Certainly, a major factor was that while the moral vitalism that animated the specific goal of abolition became institutionalized within the British structures of social and political power, the similarly inspired effort to achieve a broader and more diffuse moral reform did not. Indeed, the intellectual elites of late-nineteenth-century British society became a new network of leaders committed to skewering the pretentions and hypocrisies of the Victorian era — the Bloomsbury Group. It is no small irony that many of the leading figures of this innovative and often transgressive movement were the grandchildren of Clapham Sect luminaries.

The pietism that animated the Clapham Sect in England in the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries gave way to the formalism of the late Victorian and Edwardian periods. Here the external trappings of being a “gentleman” took precedence over the reasons for being a gentleman. Put another way, why questions were abandoned for what questions. The late Victorians retained a morality that was shaped by religion, without any serious adherence to religion: a morality without metaphysics. They wanted the flower of high moral reasoning and conduct without the soil to nourish it, and, as Nietzsche observed, ethics without a metaphysical justification is a morality that will evaporate under the hot noon sun.

Rahn goes on to argue that modern America needs a new Clapham style network of dense relationships that not only advocate for moral transformation, but also for the greater metaphysical underpinning that can support that moral transformation. I find his argument compelling: the soil must precede the flower, or in religious terms, that faith is needed for good works to flourish. Still, the nature of the human heart is to prefer the external trappings of faith (the look of being a gentleman) rather than being shaped by faith itself (the reasons for being a gentleman). If we are to preserve the metaphysic, i.e., the gospel, for our grandchildren, I imagine we shall try our best, but providence will have to play as much a part in our striving as strategy.

6. The last word this week goes to Denise Uwimana, author of From Red Earth: A Rwandan Story of Healing and Forgiveness. Plough published an excerpt from her 2019 book this week in commemoration of the 30th anniversary of the Rwandan Genocide. Uwimana’s Tutsi family was the target of the genocide. Her husband was murdered, but she and her three young sons were sheltered by Hutu neighbors and survived. She would go on to found a significant NGO that offered spiritual and material help to genocide victims. In 2015, she traveled back to her home village on the anniversary of the genocide and asked if anyone had considered forgiving their attacker.

Despite my certainty, I felt apprehensive as I rose to address around five hundred people. Were they ready for this? “Has any of you been able to forgive?” I asked. To my astonishment, at least a dozen hands shot up, voices calling, “I have!” “I have!”

One was Cancilde. I knew that her husband and five of her seven children had been killed; one son and daughter had survived, having been absent on the fatal day. All eyes were on this bereaved mother as she stood to speak. “A gang of Interahamwe mobbed my house on April 9, 1994,” she began, referring to the Hutu militias that led the genocide. “My family was caught by surprise.”

She stalled, then plunged on. “A young neighbor, Emmanuel, killed my husband and five of our children. He was arrested and imprisoned the next year. But three years ago, in 2012, he was released. Before going home, Emmanuel tried to come to my house, to humble himself. But the village had learned of his arrival and staged a protest, so he could not come that night. Next morning, however, he appeared at my door, pleading for forgiveness. ‘From that day to this,’ he told me, ‘I have felt continual shame.’”

Cancilde paused again, then concluded quietly, “My heart had been freed from hate by then, because we widows had been reading the gospel together. Its message prepared my heart to forgive.”

Uwimana goes on to share how Cancilde and Emmanuel reconciled and remain surrogate family to this day. Plough titled the excerpt “How Far Does Forgiveness Reach?,” and from Cancilde’s testimony, I don’t think we’ve found an answer.

“Cancilde has become like a mother to me,” [Emmanuel] said quietly. “When I need advice, I go to her. Before I got married, I talked over the details with her. She is the local official who authorized my marriage.”

Cancilde broke in, “Emmanuel is the one I ask for help when my house needs repair. He comes any time I ask, to replace a window or mend the roof. If my cow has problems, I call him. And he knows he’s always welcome to share a meal at my home. He is my son!”

Strays:

subscribe to the Mockingbird newsletter

COMMENTS


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *