Humility is a notorious riddle. The Desert Fathers, for example, said humility is foundational, but they warned that it is always ready to make its escape. They left us cautionary tales of sages who, at the end of their journey, were shipwrecked by arrogance. The issue is not that humility is hard to attain. That is true of any virtue. It’s that humility is hard to pursue directly. It seems to invite vigilant self-forgetfulness or some such paradox. Do not let your left hand know what your right hand is doing. There is also the issue of visibility. Humility is a shy virtue. It might get attention indirectly, like when someone is recognized for sacrificing an advantage for another person’s benefit, but the humble person isn’t interested in recognition. They are concerned with someone else. Even when humility is in the limelight, its goodness isn’t dependent on an outcome. There is a tragic beauty to selfless devotion, even if the sacrifice changes nothing. Or imagine a counterexample, where yielding to a greater good really frustrated someone. If it provoked too much internal resistance, even though they conceded in the end, humility would disappear. Unlike courage or gratitude, the more humility becomes strenuous and obvious, the less it retains its soul.
This hiddenness seems essential. The truest humility is virtually invisible. C. S. Lewis noted this: When you meet a humble person, you won’t notice their humility. You might reflect on how sincerely they enjoyed their time with you, or you might notice how naturally you slid into genuine conversation. That humility is so mercurial suggests something about how it can be found. (Although I almost wrote how it can be attained, but that is what I want to dissuade you of.) Because it seems that we do not so much pursue humility as let ourselves be courted — and sometimes hunted — by it.
It is like trying to force ourselves to sleep: Everyone knows we can only “fall” asleep. Humility and sleep require a will to surrender — not to any influence but to accept and invite a certain experience. But the metaphor is just as useful for how it falls short. For example, sleepiness is pleasant, whereas being humbled rarely is. And humility is a spiritual awakening, not a kind of drowsiness — what the Orthodox call nepsis. Egotistical motives lurking within our good desires (often not so hidden to others) are brought to our awareness. Quickly you see that humility — unlike niceness — requires grit to grow through tough experiences. It’s not that the freedom of humility is not pleasant but that its entrance into our souls is not always like a demure guest. It can be more like an unsparing spotlight.
This is a key distinction: Humility’s entrance and pilgrimage are different than its final rest. This is probably the case with all the virtues. Becoming courageous means facing our fears. Becoming a leader entails being overwhelmed and confused by responsibilities. Chastity requires we become sensitive to the movement of our attractions. And so on. So what are the tough prerequisites by which gentle humility apprentices us? Prayer is its main school, and by it, to love God with all our being; but prayer must be joined to other practices if it’s to remain authentic. This practical element is what I want to explore. Namely, the courage to be honest with ourselves, about our motives, actions, and judgements — and to do so through the lens of a startling truth, that each of us is meant to bring about profound goodness within the life we share with others. These are the two parts of humility’s journey: its pilgrimage and its end. We are asked not merely to endure but to embrace moral exposure because, despite all appearances, it has been revealed that we are learning to play a vital role in an unimaginably beautiful harmony.
When either part of this vision is lost, we are headed not toward humility but to disgruntled pessimism or self-centered optimism. The path can be entered from either side, and both have their appeal, but forward movement happens with both sides in view. For example, seeing people join together in love for a worthy cause can awaken a desire to find our place in the greater whole. But that doesn’t automatically create the will and courage to embrace exposure. That remains a choice, because having our standard operating procedures questioned, be it ever so kindly, at any stage of the journey, can feel like opening the door to a suspicious stranger. Entering from the other side, the willingness to see our part in some breakdown doesn’t automatically ennoble us. It easily, and perhaps often, ends in a guilty moment; we simply discover a mistake to avoid in the future. Instead, to realize during an admission of wrong that we are not being investigated like a faulty cog but that our presence is vital and desired within the greater good — that can lift our face to a homecoming just over humility’s horizon. So how do we consent to being lead along a descending trail with signage to higher ground? There are two markers from contemplative theology that can keep us oriented.
The greater good is the big picture. The smaller one is our role in it. Getting those lenses lined up and in focus can spare us unnecessary misery. The big picture is (entertaining the possibility) that the world was made and is groaning to become a theophany, a theatre of divine life, and that it still moves and exists in God’s ceaseless procession. Atoms are held together by nuclear force; stars are held together by gravity; but the worlds they compose are a surprise. The world we inhabit, and the smaller ones within it, do not hold themselves together. They pulse with greed and violence, but they hold together in Christ. Whether or not we think we can sustain the energy for that vision, or get ourselves to feel it, a quiet awareness of the world’s true face can slowly reset our hopes and expectations — undo society’s factory settings. We start to look up and out, and get small enough to learn from the lilies and the sparrows.

Secondly, we can scarcely imagine who we are meant to become.[1] We hardly know what part we will be called on to play on any given day. Instead of foresight, we are given a sense of what and whom to love — often in a still, small voice — it is the Spirit’s inclination to self-donation. When we are lacking that, we need only ask, what father would give his son a stone if he asks for bread — and it will progressively become clear. A parent knows to love their child, but what will be required of them becomes evident with time. An artist begins with a compelling idea, but who knows where it will take them, or if they will be up to executing it? Following the subtle movements of love will join us to God’s current within the world.
Once we make it that far, Jesus and all the saints say we are most susceptible to releasing humility’s hand. They warn of the dangers for anyone who imagines they are signing up for “the good team.” We get possessive of our generosity, and the gift of love starts to feel like a private investment of our time and energy. Trying to help others, we run up against our own shortcomings and tighten our grip on our innocence. We sense, with some dread, that despite a deep resonance with our vocation, no role will keep us filled. So either we fit ourselves to winning at a career and mining its rewards, or else acknowledge that the transcendent instinct within us is neither neurotic nor pacifiable. All of this and more.
Somehow, James says, without lying to ourselves we can sum this up as joy. Jesus, no less, congratulates us when our truest desires are frustrated by opposition. Gregory of Nyssa centered his contemplative spirituality on the experience of this very gap. Life with Christ is a pilgrimage into God in blissful self-transcendence — an epektasis, “stretching forward” — an endless expansion of heart.[2] But it will stretch us. Inevitably, in the ways we least want to be stretched. But as we develop a feel for this expansive stretch, not a twisting of the arm, we will find ourselves steadier and more responsive.
Still, humility stays hidden. At the height of humility’s influence in the soul, instead of inflating itself, it breathes a quiet resilience into the other virtues. The experience of humility feels like the freedom to give way, an absence of friction at whatever presents itself as truer, better, or more beautiful. This is humility’s “falling” awake hinted at above. Humility might move us to silence or disagreement, but it doesn’t teach us to feel humble. We are most humble when we least know it because we are caught up. If we defer to someone, we give way instinctively — not in order to be humble but to be grateful for the wisdom they brought to an issue, and more so when the solution was not what we supposed. Or imagine, after weeks of effort, an embarrassingly small amount of feedback shows us what hasn’t been working well. Niceness smiles and nods. Humility, in contrast, can be disoriented at what was obvious all along, but given the chance to be nourished and refined, to better place our finger on the pulse, it gives way and “rejoices with the truth.”[3] We come to trust the invasion of something better, to open our partiality and emptiness to an unforeseen wholeness, and welcome the discomfort of this foreign good as the cost of entry into God’s fullness.
[1] See Romans 8:18–21, Colossians 3:4, or 1 John 3:2.
[2] For example, Gregory of Nyssa, Homilies on the Song of Songs (Homilies 8 and 12).
[3] 1 Corinthians 13:6








What a deeply-considered piece. Thank you for taking the time to work through this notoriously difficult-to-pin-down virtue.
Reading it, a couple of thoughts. First, the old saw that humility isn’t so much thinking less of yourself than it is thinking of yourself less remains a reliable polestar.
Second, and associated: it’s about seeing things for what they really are. I think about the first chapter of First John, the emphasis on “light” (even: “God is light”!), and the head-shaking reminder that if you consider yourself without sin, you’re deceiving yourself “and the truth is not within [you].”
Finally, that seeing things as they really are requires attention, properly-directed — which might be to say, not so much “directed” as open and receptive. It’s soft palms, not white knuckles. Thinking here of Simone Weil, who said that attention at its highest and purest form is indistinguishable from prayer — which as you note, is a necessary element of humility, too. Writes Weil:
“Attention consists of suspending our thought, leaving it detached, empty, and ready to be penetrated by the object; it means holding in our minds, within reach of that thought, but on a lower level and not in contact with, the diverse knowledge we have acquired, which we are forced to make use of. Our thought should be in relation to all particular and already formulated thoughts, as a man on a mountain, who, as he looks forward, sees also below him, without actually looking at them, a great many forests and plains. Above all our thought should be empty, waiting, not seeking anything, but ready to receive in its naked truth the object that is to penetrate it.”
That last sentence describes the posture of humility to a T.