The Death of the English Major

Who do we become when we have no language to make sense of our daily experience?

Sam Bush / 11.14.23

If you are a liberal arts graduate, you have likely heard more than enough jokes deriding the value of your education. How do you get an art history major off your porch? Pay for the pizza. What did the philosophy major ask his client? “Why do you want fries with that?” A few weeks ago, the jokes fell flat when Australia Catholic University disbanded much of its humanities department, laying off 32 full-time academics in philosophy, history, and theology while completely cutting medieval and early modern studies. There are several reasons for downsizing, but the main reason seems to be that the humanities don’t pay the bills anymore. With so many resources going toward scientific research and so many students prioritizing making money after graduation, supporting Intro to Church History or Metaphysics 101 is just plain unsustainable.

Australia may feel like a safe distance on the other side of the globe, but the rest of the world is not far behind. In the Wall Street Journal, Jennifer Frey recently wrote that administrators across academia have “adopted the argument that liberal arts are a luxury that cannot be afforded in times of austerity.” Not only are humanities strapped for cash already, but fewer and fewer students even want to major in English or philosophy. In the age where scientific reasoning and utilitarian economics reign supreme, it just doesn’t make sense to study poetry.

Science has become so embedded in the modern psyche that it now serves as the lingua franca of our time. To express any experience of pleasure we use the term dopamine hit. When going outside we say we’re “getting our Vitamin D intake.” As historian Justin Smith notes about the burgeoning field of happiness studies:

In the happiness experts’ efforts to isolate the fundamental molecules of happiness and to measure happiness by quantitative means, they have wittingly or not rendered happiness into something money-like, where having more units of it makes you better off and having fewer does the opposite.

And so we monitor ourselves the same way we do our cars, as if getting enough electrolytes and supplements in our system will help us work better and live longer. This kind of self-optimization talk is a product of our scientific worldview and our growing apathy for the humanities.

Seeing the world and ourselves through a scientific lens gives us an heir of certainty. There is something satisfying about the ideas of objective truth and repeatable outcomes. For centuries, science has been the bedrock of secular society, a sure anchor in times of trouble. When the pandemic struck fear into our hearts, many would recite the mantra “follow the science.” The modern creed by which many people now live begins with the belief that “Science is Real.” It’s even popped up on car bumper stickers and lawn signs. And yet, such a resolute declaration is still a statement of faith, no different than the first line of the Apostles Creed.

To be sure, our lives depend on the benefits of modern science — we would all be in trouble without the wonders of medicine, hygiene, and engineering — but knowledge itself does not provide a firm foundation for human flourishing. People refer to science as if it’s a tome of information that is timeless and undisputable whereas, in truth, science is constantly changing. Case in point, just take a gander at the dinosaurs. Like every other school of thought, scientific norms aren’t established by one empirical authority, but by tens of thousands of people who are constantly debating each other’s interpretations. Like the internet, science (or, at least, our understanding of science) is made in our image because it is explored and operated by human beings. The puzzle of life can be put together one atom at a time, but we won’t be able to make out the image of the puzzle unless a divine light bulb is turned on overhead.

It’s no coincidence that theology was coined in the middle ages as the queen of sciences. Concerned with the study of God, who created all things, theology therefore pertains to all intellectual pursuits. Theology can make use of other sciences to make its teaching more clear, but practical knowledge found in engineering or mathematics exists on a lower order, deriving their certainty from theology itself. Human reason is, in and of itself, a beautiful thing, but it only finds its true meaning in light of grace and faith. The irony of Australian Catholic University downsizing its theology department is that upholding theology as higher education has always been standard Catholic doctrine.

Time will tell the exact ramifications of this shift in academia, but it’s hard not to think the stakes are high. What’s lost when we only think of ourselves as perfectable machines in need of a new training regimen? Who do we become when we have no language to make sense of our daily experience?

While researchers may provide us an endless amount of information, we still need the poets and playwrights, the theologians and novelists, to help us see the world in all its splendor. As Frederick Buechner wrote, “Truth in the sense of fullness, of the way things are, can at best be only pointed to by the language of poetry — of metaphor, image, symbol — as it is used in the prophets of the Old Testament and elsewhere.” We may need the general sciences to keep us alive, but we need more than that to help us flourish.

When you apply metrics to the humanities, the outcomes are directly measurable in terms of GDP output. When you measure utility for your life or society as a whole, it shortchanges you in the long run. Wisdom, on the other hand, has very few short term gains and a much longer term return on investment. Wisdom can’t make you think, but it can change the way you see the world and yourself. Wisdom can’t solve your marriage, but wisdom can keep you married. Who a society is in the measure and span of decades and centuries is precisely what the humanities contributes. And it is immeasurable.

The loss of the humanities seems to go hand in hand with the secularization of society. Our insistence on the cold, hard proof of science has led to a disconnect from our emotional life. We may come to understand the neurobiological makeup of anxiety, but understanding should never be mistaken for peace. Science may help us in all sorts of ways, but it is hardly a helpful guide when it comes down to the unprovable areas of life such as justice and mercy. Beyond the scope of knowing lies a world that transcends proof altogether. A world that is full of imagination and mystery, of hope and sorrow. This is what the language of Christianity brings to the table. It recognizes a domain far more vast than human comprehension, a world full of music and metaphor and, yes, even art history. It provides a lens that is meant to focus squarely on the heart. In that sense, it is far more real than anything that can be proven. It may not make you rich, but it will make your life worth living.

subscribe to the Mockingbird newsletter

COMMENTS


5 responses to “The Death of the English Major”

  1. Blake Nail says:

    i’m saddened to hear the changes being made but love this article !

  2. Dave Johnson says:

    Great article! As an undergrad back in the Dark Ages I was a double major (Biblical Lit and European History)—and no, upon graduation I did not have a list of job offers (actually started with a Washington Post paper route)—but thirty-plus years later I can say although it hasn’t yielded overwhelming opulence, it has indeed enriched my life (and the many relationships therein) immeasurably—and I’d do it again. You the man, Sam!

  3. Jim Layman says:

    I was an English major with a minor in European history. I became part of an Religious Missionary order and 40 years of campus ministry has continued to stir my reading, thinking, and writing abilities that were trained in my Lit, Composition, and History classes. I was ministering at MIT when the Institute installed a “writing requirement” for undergrad techies. Absolutely necessary.

  4. Brenda says:

    This was so timely as my son is a freshman considering changing his major….after the pandemic choosing an “essential” job in a STEM field seemed like the smart choice, but his heart and interests lie in the liberal arts. I was thrilled to share this with him for further consideration.

  5. Jeremiah Webster says:

    Thank you for affirming the centrality of the humanities, not just within the halls of academia, but within the Christian life as well. Esau has sold his literary inheritance for a mess of utilitarian pottage. Your essay is a brilliant brief for the defense. University administrators nationwide: take heed.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *