Around 300 BCE by Zeno of Citium began a philosophical school that came to be named after the porches, stoa, where it was taught: Stoicism. For Zeno and many of the generations of stoics who followed him, personal virtue is to be exclusively valued above all else. The one who possesses virtue has no need of anything or anyone else. According to Cicero, even during extremely painful torture and separation from all friends and family, the virtuous person is maximally happy (De Finibus 3.42). Happiness and circumstance have nothing to do with one another. The stoic does not care about the judgment of others or the ups and downs of all our lives. For the stoic, dispassionate acceptance is the norm.
In this century, the zeitgeist is not stoic. We care how we are judged, perhaps to a fault. Without the pursuit of a common ideal (like virtue), we feel every judgment and reward in our lives, unable to cope with the extremes. Our lives are now fully shared by this media, and the explosion of the “helping professions.” Nearly a quarter of all adults below the age of 44 received mental health treatment last year, including almost one in three white people. “It Takes A Village” may be about raising a child, but the common concern and therapy for our individual selves in community has become the cultural norm.

We are coming to suspect any greater good, or to accept those things that cannot be changed. Here, the cruelty of modern socialization couldn’t be more plain. Drug overdoses have quintupled. In the past twenty years, suicide is up 30%.
In those twenty years church attendance has also halved. Unlike the “Freakonomics” approach that connects the dots of outcomes to define causes, the loss of stoicism as a culturally accepted response to our conditions and the parallel loss of numbers coming together to worship is counterintuitive. You would think that if we realized that it took a village to live through our lives we would gather more, not less.
But we isolate more than ever. And we die from that isolation. We embrace the isolation of the stoic with none of the faith in a higher good to overcome what pains or threatens us. We do not share each other’s vulnerability in faith, but we have determined that it’s wrong to soldier on through life. We fail at reaching out beyond ourselves in faith while the validity of a stoic mindset is losing its relevance in the culture. When the only higher good toward which we reach is nothing but ourselves, then it shouldn’t be surprise when our outstretched hands come back empty.
I, like many Baby Boomers, had an isolated childhood in a dysfunctional family while going to church. This isolation was shared with God and is the direct inverse of the godless village of the cultural sensibility we are told to embrace. Yet, I admit that I am a stoic. I am quite certain I broke my wrist in a biking fall almost twenty years ago, but “I’m fine.” And it healed. In a raging mid-century family, I accepted the yelling and somehow knew that God was there.
In my earliest memory, I was both stoic and was never alone. We do not make ourselves, so stoics use what God gives us. God also gives us the church. And psychotherapy. And all the abilities to lose ourselves.
But God also gives us faith, a silent courage in the face of hardship. Courage manifests through faith because faith directs itself to a God outside ourselves. A God greater than virtue itself.
Last week the entire country did on TV what it used to do in church — we came together to watch our one cross-cultural national event: the Super Bowl. In that game, one human became a focus, leading his team to victory in a courageous fashion. Patrick Mahomes embodied the acceptance of what he could not control: he was, before our eyes, a fully manifestly stoic, living through extreme pain to do what he loved. Fully injured, then reinjured, in the last seconds, his singular pursuit of victory somehow overcame his pain. Mahomes was in himself and with those he loved, his brothers, who knew not to help beyond their full abiding love for him, because he, alone, was with his pain, but in his pain he was in God’s hand.
We are what God has made in us. We are not the judgment of the world, Facebook, or the score of the Super Bowl. We are stoics, we are children of full fragility, we are alone and we are fully, undeniably with God. It is a blessing to be loved by a village, but ultimately our lives come down to the essential connection with Jesus, alone, with Him.








Duo, this is an awesome analysis and fascinating to learn a bit about the value of the stoic perspective. Thank you for sharing your rich thought process on this most important subject!
THANKYOU
[…] that promise inner tranquility, but an inner state that exists independent of circumstance (as it was for the Stoics), then so many attempts to be more happy are misbegotten from the […]
[…] In Mockingbird: The Loss of Stoicism […]