The Shapelessness of Evil

A Discussion of Halloween (2018)

Ian Olson / 10.30.26

Happy Halloweek, boils and ghouls! Halloween is right around the corner, and so is Michael Myers, back to show everyone why he is the undisputed master slasher! Blaine Grimes, Blake Collier, Caleb Stallings, and I are in our Halloween best and invite you to join us in watching Halloween (2018).

Ian: I picked this because it takes me back so vividly to October 2018 and seeing it with my wife, Kristin, and her sister, Anna. Weird as it may sound, this flick lights my heart up like a dozen M-80s in a jack-o’-lantern. I was excited for Michael Myers to return to the big screen and for a new generation to reckon with the horror of The Shape.

Caleb: This was the first movie my wife, Aleece, and I ever saw together. Our second date! It’ll always be important to me for that reason alone, but it’s also important to me because it’s a good Halloween sequel!

Blake: This movie will forever hold a dear place in my marriage as the first film I took my wife to that caused her to cry and to lose sleep. The first Halloween she watched, she didn’t even bat an eye. This one was just too much for her.

Caleb: Wild that we all associate this, for good or for ill, with our wives!

Blake: Except Blaine, who just saw it for the first time, right?

Blaine: Yeah. I’ve only ever seen the OG and this one.

Blake: That is WILD.

Caleb: Do you think this one stands out more than others, Ian?

Ian: In some significant ways, yes. Halloween (2018) resets the board by proceeding as if there had never been a sequel to the 1978 Halloween. Even titling this film Halloween shows how it positions itself as spiritual successor to the original, and it kind of implicitly announces that nothing with that word and a number after it matters.

Caleb: I will admit, I am a sucker for all the various timelines and reboots. But I think this is far and away the best one.

Ian: Don’t get me wrong, I enjoy certain sequels before this, but it’s largely in the same way I enjoy the Friday the 13th sequels: schlocky fun.

Blake: I don’t hate any of the sequels. But this and its subsequent two films were the first time I felt giddy about being in Haddonfield again.

Ian: Halloween (2018) definitely seeks to accomplish something amid its slasher spectacle. I think it wants to go back to basics in showcasing Michael as the evacuated site and vessel of evil: The Shape.

Caleb: It’s fascinating how they have to cast the horror of Michael killing five people in 1978 against the larger horror of the subsequent 40 years in American society. Michael isn’t the most prolific serial killer. There have been worse threats than him, but still: he is an avatar of the shapeless Shape of evil.

So I think Laurie gets it right later when she talks about how hard and dark the world is. All of us have to be prepared for it. The question is How can we be?

Ian: You’re actually approaching something I’m sensing this time around. Although this film officially disavows forty years of sequels, it nevertheless assumes their lore, after a fashion, precisely because the Michael of Halloween (1978) murdered five people, but there’s a mythos to Michael here as though he had carried out everything in those sequels.

Caleb: It definitely reckons with its own lore. Laurie’s granddaughter’s friends hear rumors that Laurie was Michael’s sister, which alludes to Halloween 2 (1981). But the truth is much scarier: he’s not related to Laurie at all. His stalking and tormenting her is utterly inscrutable; random. And I think a thesis of this movie is that the world is the same: full of random horror that we can’t ever truly parse out in this life. Michael just happens to be one personification of that.

Ian: One of the most satisfying things to me was how the inmates at the asylum chitter and cry out when the mask is presented to Michael, like they sense a power drawing near. That shapeless evil seeks a vessel but also a shape. Michael is at the ready but seeks union with the mask. It’s an anti-wholeness: a complete evacuation and readiness for radical evil. It makes me think that evil, which preexists mankind, seeks man’s shape because man bears the image of God.

Blake: I definitely think you have something here, and I think there is text in this and the other two movies that speaks to his desire to “exist” or be incarnated into a form that he knows he can never be.

Ian: He? Or it? The mask confers shape upon this evil and operates almost like a magic wand. At the very least, it’s a totem. And I love the idea of its bearing a power no one would have thought to confer upon it or would ever recognize without Michael’s adopting it.

I love that this film portrays the paranormal, superhuman quality of The Shape in a more subdued fashion than previous sequels that simply told the audience, for instance, “Michael is the result of a cult ceremony!” It shows us actions and consequences that eerily exceed what is normally possible in those actions, such as depicting the union of man and mask at the gas station as an unleashing of chthonic power. And that’s more in keeping with Halloween (1978). This series is strongest when it doesn’t attempt to explain the evil of Michael Myers and simply depicts it.

Blaine: I thought the podcaster/journalist duo served as an indictment of attempts to rationalize or reason with this kind of evil.

Ian: I completely agree, and I think that that posture is summed up in the male podcaster telling Laurie, “I don’t believe in the Boogeyman.”

Blake: Agreed, as well as a knock on the true crime podcasting mass industry.

Ian: Yeah, it really does a disservice to people by portraying evil as explicable, as something that can be diagnosed and understood fairly simply and then packaged as a product. Even if it wasn’t the writers’ intention, I think this film shows that failing to reckon with the gravity of evil fails ourselves and our fellows.

I think that’s a theme it attempts to explore because Karen, Laurie’s daughter, accuses Laurie of projecting paranoia and neurosis onto her. She blasts Laurie’s outlook with the most roseate cope imaginable: “The world is not a dark and evil place! It is full of love and understanding, and I’m not letting your psychotic rants confuse me or convince me otherwise!”

Blake: I think that if what happened to Laurie happened to me, I probably would have done almost exactly the same thing she did in its wake. I’d isolate and prepare, because really, unless you are very well adjusted and know in a profound way that fear is just as much an eater of the soul as denial, I’m not sure that there’s a way around that in a broken world. So while I agree that Laurie is a little off, I see how that is a real response we can expect from people. I have a lot of compassion for her.

I have less for Karen, aside from the fact that she was a kid and didn’t understand the horrors her mother witnessed. She’s in denial for most of her life and most of this film’s runtime. I think she’s trying to act like this isn’t real and that all the things her mother taught her are insane. But when we see her snap into the training Laurie gave her as a kid, it shows how it’s all still there, ready to do what’s needed, and it’s awesome.

Ian: I’m rewatching this now and I have four kids. What you said, Blake, helps me articulate something I sensed on this rewatch: “Train up a child in the way they should go.” Laurie tried her best to do so and inevitably, as all parents do, failed in some regards. But in light of what you just said, I am compelled by how, when the time comes, Karen’s denials dissolve in the face of what’s happening, and her preparation kicks right back into gear, and she knows exactly what to do. And that’s the point. That’s what you are to do as a parent: to equip and prepare your child for a world that is dialectically both things. There is love and light, but it also is brimming with darkness and hate.

Blake: That moment where Karen clicks into her training is easily the best singular moment in the movie. I honestly think this movie is about her, even though she doesn’t get the most screen time. Like a lot of horror now, this does traffic in trauma and generational hurt, but it does so within the confines of an evil that operates outside of human categories. The horror is not a strained allegory for grief or trauma but simply the context in which the characters live and have to navigate to confront this unknowable evil. In this way, I think it’s much smarter and refuses to therapeutically or materialistically explain away the horror by way of allegory.

Ian: Well, we know Blake’s favorite moment in this film! What about you, boys?

Caleb: I love that long tracking shot of Michael going in and out of houses, wreaking havoc. They use those same kinds of shots several times in Halloween 2, and here, it’s even more effective. He blends into the happy chaos of trick-or-treaters yet quickly and ruthlessly destroys people’s lives before they even know what’s happening. It’s bone-chilling.

Ian: For sure!

Blaine: My favorite moment is when Michael pushes Laurie off the balcony, looks away for a second, and when he looks back to the ground, Laurie is gone. This is accompanied by an ominous note in the musical score. I think it’s a perfect reversal of roles, and it signals the moment when Michael has gone from hunter to hunted.

Blake: That reversal was more ominous earlier when her granddaughter stares out the classroom window and sees Laurie standing across the street like Michael in the first one. Makes us see them on a very similar path, like he is drawing her to him to transform her. Then it fails in the scene you noted. It’s almost as if — and I know this is social heresy right now — Laurie’s trauma was drawing her closer to Michael instead of being released from him through divesting herself of her victimhood.

Ian: I could not agree more! Undergoing and recovering from harm is not equivalent to curving in on yourself via adopting the identity “victim.” And that’s really the heart of why I say Laurie’s needle points more closely toward the truth but is still several degrees out of alignment.

Suffice it to say, this feels like a genuine Halloween movie and a movie for Halloween — perfect for cozying up with your wife!

We hope you enjoyed hanging out with us ghoul-igans! We wish y’all a fun and a safe Halloween. Be sure to join us next week when we watch Dario Argento’s Inferno. Be there and be square!

subscribe to the Mockingbird newsletter

COMMENTS


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *