What is it exactly to say that our technology is haunted? The now-cliché phrase “ghost in the machine” gets bandied about completely severed from its original context (which was never even remotely paranormal but asserted a categorical mistake in the mind/body dualism of Cartesian philosophy) and then was drawn into the world of technology to describe consciousness within computers. What if, however, I were to say that all technology has a high probability of being haunted by ghosts or other paranormal entities?
You are probably shaking your heads. Don’t worry. I understand the inclination, but stick around anyways.
I have made a case elsewhere that paranormal events like séances and EVP (electronic voice phenomena) are really no different to any of the communication devices humanity has created throughout the ages. Paranormal practices and technological devices require mediation. The séance uses a table, a psychic, and perhaps knocks and taps on the walls, and EVP is captured by recording devices — analog and digital, just as phone calls, telegraphs, and text messages require tech. Mediation of any sort creates a divide between the personal and physical intimacy of in-person communication.
When I talk on the phone, I am trusting that the voice I hear on the other side which sounds like my wife is my wife. Yet what is the substance of that trust? In that moment, it can’t be proven that it is her beyond the shadow of a doubt because of the mediation which detaches that personal, physical intimacy. The knocks on the wall and the garbled voices that are distant on analog and digital are similarly disembodied and cannot be proven to be real or not real in the moment until the instance of mediation is removed.
One is simply considered acceptable and viable because it has the seal of the scientific community and the Silicon Valley tech gurus, while the other gets relegated to the heap bins of cranks, conspiracists, and those dumb people who belong back in the Dark Ages.[1] Yet the warrant for their existence are dependent on the same problem of mediation. Both require faith that with each level of remove from physicality that is involved, we can trust that it is in fact our loved ones we are communicating with while not in person.
Now that is out of the way, have you heard of the Dodleston Messages? Well, there is a whole book about it called The Vertical Plane by the man who experienced it, Ken Webster. It used to be hard to get a copy of the book, but the part of the story that I want to focus on here is well-explained by English historian Nick Poyntz:
It told the story of a man in the early 1980s, who found that his BBC Micro computer had become a conduit through which he could communicate with a man from the sixteenth century. The latter was mystified by the “box of lights” which had appeared in his house, and accused the computer owner of witchcraft. Gradually, however, as the two carried on their electronic conversations a more trusting relationship developed. The programme concluded by stating that archival research supposedly revealed that the sixteenth-century man had actually existed, and that expert linguists had concluded that the dialect and vocabulary he used was authentic to the period.[2]
Ken Webster sat down at the personal computer he rented out from the school where he taught and began sending and receiving messages into the past and back. Those who hear this story often find it to be rather dubious. Of course this can’t be true, we have not yet (the “yet” is ever-present, because the bravado of man, yada yada) developed a time machine, let alone any technology that can reach across time and communicate with someone long dead. But what is so fascinating is just how similar our technological “thought leaders” and movements like the Spiritualists are in their use of similar language and prognosticating similar futures.
Jeffrey Sconce, in his book Haunted Media, notes the similarities:
By traversing time and space at the speed of light, electronic media have always indulged the fantasy of discorporation and the hope that the human soul, consciousness, or subject could exist independently of his or her material frame.[3]
The dourer reading of this conclusion would be that we, as a culture, have become so drained of our humanity that we somehow yearn to shuck our meat suits and become like those disembodied spirits you hear about in literature, film, TV, and podcasts. Yet the best we can do is to slide our consciousness into our DMs or shapeshift identities in a fabricated virtual world.

If we go back to Ken Webster, even the most skeptical have to say that something strange happened. Most would say that it can probably be explained away, but it has now been 40 years, and nothing has been proven either way. And this is where most paranormal stories leave us. Ambiguity.
Was Webster’s house and that BBC Microcomputer haunted by a sixteenth-century man? I am willing to give it credence because, philosophically, I can problematize “rational” mediation to the point of removing any warrant for trust in the devices we use to communicate today. It has only become that much easier to argue with the influx of AI programs that have been shoehorned into every aspect of our day-to-day life already. I don’t and can’t fully trust that those I communicate with through technological mediation are actual flesh and bone beings until I meet them in person. And even then, I can only trust those moments in person. At that point, once the mediation is removed, I can shake hands, hug, talk verbally and nonverbally, etc. After that, my warrant for trust in mediated communication is bolstered but never perfectly rectified.
Ultimately, all technology is haunted because it is relaying communications as if we are nothing more than consciousness or soul constantly being uploaded to servers and downloaded as text, video, or photo. We are avatars to others until we must face each other in person. The veil of doubt is lifted, and we can know finally that the other is not in fact an actual ghost in the machine.[4]
It was Mark Fisher in his collection of essays, The Weird and the Eerie, who talked about the terminus of human interaction with technology. While discussing Nigel Kneale’s The Stone Tape, Fisher states,
Kneale’s thesis is that hauntings and ghosts are particularly intense phenomena that are literally recorded by matter … What the scientists had been looking for, apparently coincidentally, was a new, more compact and durable recording medium. But what the haunting phenomenon offers is the possibility not only of a new recording medium, but of a new player: the human nervous system itself … So what Kneale implies in the end is the breakdown of the distinction between the player and what is being played … It is as if the room — the site, it is eventually implied, of some unimaginably ancient place of sacrifice — solicits the scientists into precipitating yet another death, into playing out the same old sequence once again. The human players are themselves part of an aeons-old pattern of senseless repetition.[5]
In this way, it does not matter the means of medium — whether scientifically sanctioned or “on the fringes” — the song remains the same. Mediation must be used by somebody. Those somebodies are bred within a broken and fractured cosmos and they themselves inherit those breaks and fractures. The mediation, in this way, does not ultimately matter as the sinful HPtFTU[6] will breed the same outcomes throughout time eternal. The “stone tape” of the world records that human saga of failure and redemption and our nervous systems fast forward and rewind it every day of our existence.
This may seem highly mechanistic in its explanation, but that is really not the intent. It is just noting that the technology that we use (perhaps “caress” is more an apt term these days) is just a glitzier means for us to be felled by the ghosts of those clouds of witnesses that came before us. And yet we envision this haunt as something new, as something progressive, perhaps something that can bring us unto perfection. No technology can accomplish this feat. No ark. No divine miracle. No tabernacle. Material or immaterial technologies never could fix us. Only a primordial piece of tech that no one wanted to utilize and the person who willingly sought to use it. Only a technology of death could bring us to life. Only that medium had the means to supplant all other mediums.
[1] I despise this popular historical contrivance. It reminds me of C. S. Lewis’ use of the term “chronological snobbery” to describe each successive generation’s ability to view itself as having “arrived” and past generations were backwards or lesser than.
[2] Poyntz, Nick. “Ghost in the Machine.” Mercurius Politicus, June 14, 2016. .
[3] Sconce, Jeffrey. Haunted Media: Electronic Presence from Telegraphy to Television. Duke University Press, 2000, pg. 202.
[4] Unless you are a solipsist, but that is a whole other ball of wax.
[5] Fisher, Mark. The Weird and the Eerie. London, Repeater Books, 2016, pg. 87.
[6] The “Human Propensity to F*ck Things Up,” Francis Spufford’s acronym in his book Unapologetic.








Well, you know you had me here at ghost and time-travel. I feel that I’ve seen this concept more so (and maybe more strangely), not in ghost stories as much as modern romance stories. I’m thinking of the hit tv show “Highlander” (where a woman who was a nurse in WWII enters through a portal on a sacred landmark and time travels only to discover her husband’s famous ancestor is a complete and utter a-hole). It seems like there’s a lot of room in modern romance for the weird, in an interesting way.