The Instacart-Crab Rangoon Incident

A Modern-Day Parable

Paul Mueller / 11.19.26

I have bit of a love/hate relationship with Instacart. I have always been very particular about grocery shopping and honestly used to really enjoy it. However, as other things have crept in and occupied my time, in-person shopping started to become more and more difficult to fit in and get everything else done that I needed to during the limited numbers of hours that each weekend provides. I recently found myself with an exceptionally busy Saturday slate, a completely empty refrigerator for the upcoming week, and a list of all of the ingredients needed for our yearly homemade crab rangoon feast. It also happened to be Halloween.

We were going to make dinner, turn off the lights, hide from America’s children, and watch Agatha All Along. It was a good plan. Saturday afternoon I took some stuff to Savers. On the way home, I realized I hadn’t eaten lunch, so I stopped at Subway. While I was sitting there, I had what surely was a brilliant idea. Instacart. We hadn’t been grocery shopping in a couple of weeks, so I needed quite a bit of stuff anyway. I could put in a big grocery order and have someone deliver everything I needed to make crab rangoons and chicken fried rice. There was only one thing that I wasn’t going to trust Instacart with: wonton wrappers. Instacart shoppers cannot find wonton wrappers. I don’t know why. Maybe they exist in some sort of grocery store Bermuda Triangle. Maybe only certain people can see them. Maybe you have to believe in wonton wrappers before the wonton wrappers reveal themselves to you. Whatever the reason, I knew better than to place the fate of my wonton wrappers in the hands of my Instacart shopper. I’d been burned before. It wasn’t going to happen again.

So I placed my Instacart order and headed to Schnucks myself for the wrappers. The app said my groceries would arrive later that afternoon. Perfect. I’d get the wonton wrappers, go home, watch some football, maybe clean and organize a little more, and then groceries would magically appear at my door. I’d start cooking, and we’d eat at a respectable hour. Then we’d turn off all the lights so children would assume nobody was home and spend the rest of Halloween eating crab rangoons and watching television. It was a great plan.

I got to Schnucks and the place was absolutely packed. My first thought was Thank God I’m not doing my grocery shopping here. Some poor Instacart sucker was going to have to deal with all of this. I just needed my wonton wrappers. So I found my two packages and headed toward the checkout. The line was enormous. I checked another line. Also enormous. There I stood, holding two packages of wonton wrappers, realizing I was probably going to spend the next 45 minutes waiting to purchase approximately eight dollars’ worth of food. Then an angel appeared. Well, technically, it was a woman from the floral department wearing a red shirt. She walked over and looked at me. “Is that all you’ve got?” For a second, I thought I was in trouble. “Uh … yeah?” “Come here.” I followed her. She told me she’d just gotten back from lunch, had a couple of things to do, and figured she’d check me out. It was glorious. I had just been handed 45 minutes of my life back. Football! Relaxation! Productivity! The Lord’s face had smiled upon me. But she wasn’t finished. Before I left, she leaned in and gave me one more piece of advice. “When you leave, instead of cutting through all the lines, just go out the entrance.”

I’m sorry, what?

Apparently, if you’re stuck on the wrong side of the store and just need to leave, you can wait until somebody walks in and sneak out through the entrance. I had always felt guilty doing this. Not anymore. It had now been officially blessed by the Schnucks floral department. I walked out of that store feeling fantastic. I had beaten the system. Everything was going my way. At that moment, the Lord’s grace was resting upon me. That feeling would last approximately two hours.

I got home. I watched some football and waited without a care in the world. Eventually, I started getting just a touch nervous. I hadn’t heard anything from Instacart, even though the 4:00 p.m. – 5:00 p.m. window was getting close. Then the message arrived: Your Instacart order has been delayed. The new time was now four hours later than the original one. This was unacceptable! At least, apparently, it was unacceptable to me. I mean, they just moved the time? Can you do that? That doesn’t seem fair. They said it would be 4 p.m. Isn’t there some code or something that they have to stick to? I went from being the grateful recipient of undeserved Schnucks grace to a man consumed with self-righteous indignation in the blink of an eye.

So I did what anyone would do when faced with a minor inconvenience in the great scheme of things. I began furiously messaging the Instacart robot. I couldn’t believe this aggravation. I had plans! There were crab rangoons to make! My wife had to eat! Halloween was being ruined! Eventually, after I had sufficiently explained the great injustice that had been committed against me to an artificial intelligence customer service representative, another message appeared. My groceries would arrive sooner now. That’s more like it. Justice had been served.

And almost immediately, I realized what jerk I was being. There I was, telling Jen a couple of hours earlier about the unexpected gift I’d received at Schnucks. And now I suddenly felt like the guy in Jesus’ parable whose enormous debt gets forgiven, only to turn around and throttle the guy who owes him a few bucks. It was almost comical how on the nose it was. Apparently, my reservoir of thankfulness and grace had about a two-hour shelf life. The revised delivery window came and went. Eventually the message arrived that my shopper had started shopping, and that’s when I realized something. She was in that Schnucks. The Schnucks that I had just escaped from. The same Schnucks that I knew was absolutely packed. The Schnucks where I had stood earlier and thought, Thank God some poor Instacart sucker has to deal with this instead of me. And now I knew who that sucker was by name.

She started sending me messages.

They were out of this, something happened with that, could she substitute this? I could practically feel the chaos through the phone, and this woman was now in the middle of it, and I started feeling terrible for her. Eventually around 8:00 p.m. our groceries arrived. The poor woman looked like she had seen some things. “Honey, I’m sorry I’m so late,” she told me. “It was just terrible there.” All I could think was I know, I knew exactly how terrible it was, and I sent you in there anyway. A few hours earlier, I’d been congratulating myself because I’d gotten out of that store with my two packages of wonton wrappers with plenty of time to spare. Meanwhile, she had spent her evening fighting through the Halloween grocery apocalypse so I could stay home, watch football, and complain to a robot about being inconvenienced.

Grace for me, judgment for you. Funny how quickly that happens.

We got all the groceries put away around 8:30 p.m., and even though Jen suggested that we wait and make the crab rangoons the next night like reasonable people, I was bound and determined to get them made that night like I had planned. She was gracious enough to help me, and together we knocked them out pretty quick and even had fun doing it together. Eventually we popped those first crab rangoons into our mouths around 9:30 p.m., and they were indeed delicious. Not long after that, we went to bed. So much for our relaxing Halloween evening of crab rangoons, chicken fried rice, and television. Instead, I had spent most of the evening nervously checking my phone and worrying about whether I should turn the porch light on for the Instacart driver and risk attracting trick-or-treaters. And we did wait until the next day for the chicken fried rice. But dinner was good, and everything was fine. And I suppose I learned something, or more accurately, I was reminded of something I will undoubtedly need to learn again next week. I really like grace when I’m the one receiving it. I’m considerably less enthusiastic about it when I’m the one being asked to give it. Maybe that’s why grace is grace. It’s easy to be gracious when your groceries arrive on time, the line moves quickly, dinner goes according to plan, and the floral lady secretly lets you out the wrong door. The harder kind shows up when things don’t go according to plan. When somebody inconveniences you. When you’re hungry. When it’s late. That’s when you find out whether grace is something you believe in or just something you enjoy receiving. And if I’m being honest? I’m still working on that one.

subscribe to the Mockingbird newsletter

COMMENTS


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *