Everyone Wants a Revolution, but No One Wants to Die

Shifting Goalposts and Tiny-but-Mighty Christianity

Todd Brewer / 11.18.26

You see the ads on Instagram, which send you to a clean website with free shipping. A mission statement spans the top of the screen that reads, “unassuming. revolutionary.” You browse for precisely eleven seconds before tapping the purchase button. Two days later, a black cardboard box with a matte finish and all-caps lettering arrives. You’ve bought what Ben Schott has described as a “bland.”

Blands, Schott contends, seek to accomplish two incompatible ideals. Like every start-up looking to attract investments, blands aim “to disrupt and disintermediate a smug status quo, or originate and dominate an entirely new niche.” And yet for all these high aspirations, blands pursue a normalcy that verges into mediocrity by “slavishly obeying an identikit formula of business model, look and feel, and tone of voice.” This familiarity is not a failure but the secret to their success. By striving to change the world while also feeling recognizably familiar, blands can have their cake and eat it too. They are revolutionary in their simplicity, extraordinarily ordinary.

The bland is the life hack in product form, designed in the labs of Madison Avenue and funded by venture capital firms. Simple yet radical. Promising you everything while asking for very little. Small but mighty.

Like life hacks and blands, “small” is having a bit of moment, and it’s easy to see why. The difficulties we face seem too large to change ourselves. Each new day can feel less like a new opportunity and more like the start of dystopian movie we’ve seen before. Another of your passwords has become compromised; the ice caps are melting; and Starbucks is introducing surveillance pricing. For those who must suffer to live through history, small is not just possible but likely. Small is a way of controlling what you can when everything else feels out of control. This was the theme of a recent New York Times newsletter entitled, “How to Feel Hopeful When Everything is Falling Apart.” Recommendations include: picking up trash, reading the local newspaper, and giving blood. When the world feels too big, make it smaller. You do your part, the next right thing, or the least bad alternative.

It’s no wonder that everyone is talking about habit and virtues. In the face of impossibilities beyond our ability, the best hope is to leverage incremental change for disproportionate effect. As if magic were actually real. We recycle to stop climate change, learn a new language with just five minutes a day, and take vitamin supplements to expiate years of gluttony. “Improve thyself” with a new routine that promises you will do more with less. Change your life in just ten easy steps.

Everyone wants a revolution, but nobody wants to die.

For their part, many Christians are anything but immune to the tiny-but-mighty trend. They aren’t explicitly selling a bland, but it sure sounds like they are. With slogans like “revolutionary faithfulness,” “quiet radicality,” or “disruptive witness,” small is billed as the latest and greatest. Jesus didn’t demand the faith of a mustard tree but the faith of a mustard seed. The ordinary is extraordinary, the simple exceptional. Here, the many paradoxes of the New Testament abound into oblivion. Radical faithfulness, many say, isn’t manifest in heroic acts of piety but in the normalcy of common decency. Throw parties as acts of radical hospitality. In an age of lies, teach your children to tell the truth. Find your calm in the storm. Be the smallest flicker of candlelight in a dark world.

Calling something revolutionary, however, doesn’t make it so — no matter how much blanding you give it. Indeed, there is a doublespeak within these apparent paradoxes that seems perfectly happy to maintain the status quo. The goalposts of the law are lowered, and everyone gets to feel good over having done next to nothing. It misleads people to think they are living radical, countercultural lives by tipping an extra 5%, making empty land acknowledgements, or donating used clothes to make room for this month’s credit card bill.

What makes Christianity radical has little to do with an antagonistic unpopularity in a world gone mad but with the way its message, its hope, its ideals so directly push against a human nature. How this new creation conflicts or corresponds with modern beliefs and ethics is largely incidental. The life of faith is what no one would choose for themselves. It is not the fulfillment of our being but the movement from the cross to empty tomb — to be “born from above” (Jn 3:7) into something altogether new.

Jesus didn’t call his disciples to be well-adjusted Roman citizens with good reputations and a comfortable, middle-class lifestyle. He wasn’t interested in his followers living small lives of ordinary virtue; instead, to take up their cross and follow him.

While standing on the temple mount of Jerusalem, Jesus watched as a poor widow gave away two mites to the treasury (Mk 12:41–44). Calling his disciples together, Jesus praised the woman’s gift. He did not do so in order to esteem small acts of kindness or because he believed God would multiply our meager offerings like the loaves and the fishes. No, the widow was praised for her paltry gift because it was everything she had. Her offering was not the least she could do but all she could do. Dropping those coins into the treasury left her beyond destitute. With no social support or future financial prospects, her only recourse was to depend upon God’s unfailing provision and care. Though we will hold on to our two precious mites if it’s the last thing we do, she freely leapt into the wild uncertainty of God’s grace. Those who lose their lives will save it. Those who have lost everything will be found.

The real revolution we need doesn’t consist in small steps of half measures that only seem crazy when compared to the latest headlines. We don’t need a new life hack or a Christian bland that makes life feel more manageable. No, we need mountains moved by the faith of a mustard seed — and a God who raises the dead to life.

subscribe to the Mockingbird newsletter

COMMENTS


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *