Another Week Ends

The Right Way to Load a Dishwasher, Gen Z doubts, The Big Relief, and the People’s Pontiff

1. “Make sure your plates are separate, your bowls aren’t nested, and nothing is sitting where water can’t reach it.” This is the most useful advice in today’s column, so I thought I’d give it to you upfront. We’re talking here about the right way to load a dishwasher. Why? Because according to Ellen Cushing at the Atlantic:

The dishwasher is not just the weird wet box we share our homes with — it’s the site of so many of our cultural and individual values. Loading the dishwasher is, don’t get me wrong, about loading the dishwasher, but I’ve come to understand that it is also about efficiency and optimization, space and time, cleanliness and disgust.

It’s an enduring mystery, how the dishwasher works, and varying loading strategies can come between roommates, spouses, families. One person loads like a “Scandinavian architect,” one like a “raccoon on meth.” Cushing doesn’t think of a poorly loaded dishwasher as a moral failure. But “being unwilling to get better at it might be.” Thus, tip #2: “The general rule is that the bottom rack is subject to more forceful spray, so you want your sturdier items there and your daintier stuff on the top.” Tip #3: “Rinsing isn’t necessary.” GOOD NEWS! Enzymic detergent likes a little sauce.

Here is what else I can tell you about dishwashers: They are a miracle. The modern water-pressure-powered dishwasher was invented by Josephine Cochran, a socialite who was expected to host a lot of dinner parties but hated cleaning up after them. She built a dishwasher in the shed behind her house and, in doing so, helped kick off what Helen Keller would later call the “startling revolution” that rearranged women’s domestic responsibilities, and therefore their sense of what was possible. Today’s dishwashers save about 230 hours of labor a year: Nearly 10 days, every year, to do something other than wash the dishes. In a water-scarce world, they are even more valuable. Rinsing dishes takes one and a half to two gallons of water a minute; a really good dishwasher, Barnes told me, takes three to five gallons a wash.

Yes, for the gift of the dishwasher we can thank Josephine Cochran and God.

2. That is, if you believe in Him. As it seems many of us do. As noted earlier this year, Christianity is not [currently] declining in America. At the New York Times, journalist Lauren Jackson has been doing some searching, thorough reporting for a new series “Believing.” Apparently 92 percent of Americans say “they hold a spiritual belief in a god, human souls or spirits, an afterlife, or something ‘beyond the natural world.’”

Jackson reasons that people haven’t found a satisfying alternative to religion:

For the last few decades, much of the world has tried to go without God, a departure from most of recorded history. More than a billion people globally and about a third of Americans have tried to live without religion. Studies in recent years have offered insights into how that is going. The data doesn’t look good. […]

Actively religious people tend to report they are happier than people who don’t practice religion. Religious Americans are healthier, too. They are significantly less likely to be depressed or to die by suicide, alcoholism, cancer, cardiovascular illness or other causes. In a long-term study, doctors at Harvard found that women who attended religious services once a week were 33 percent less likely to die prematurely than women who never attended. That’s because, said Tyler J. VanderWeele, an author on the Harvard study, “they had higher levels of social support, better health behaviors and greater optimism about the future.”

Religiously affiliated Americans are more likely to feel gratitude (by 23 percentage points), spiritual peace (by 27 points) and “a deep sense of connection with humanity” (by 15 points) regularly than people without a religious affiliation.

Lest believers become self-congratulatory, we ought to keep in mind the ways religion is uniquely poised to harm. The condemnation and judgment that traffics in so-called Christian spaces is well and rightly documented, and Jackson notes that “about a third of Americans who have left religion appear to be doing just fine.”

Either way, it is misguided to focus on outcomes — the utility of religion — over the truth of what it professes. Religion can’t just become another way to optimize your life.

Some have tried. Jackson describes secular community gatherings with pop music, morality talks, free food — but “None of us became regulars.” Going for any reason other than faith itself — community, music, art — leaves you with little reason to stick around, especially once it’s not convenient. Churches ought to recognize that what makes them weird is not necessarily what is going to turn people away; it may be the only reason to keep going.

Jackson wonders if people are seeking security in a time when much feels out of control.

There is plenty of evidence, though, that people aren’t just religious because of insecurity or instability. Highly educated people are more likely than people who attended only high school to go to religious services weekly. Additionally, Hindus, Jews, Mainline Protestants and Muslims are all more likely than religiously unaffiliated people to have at least a college degree. These are people who tend to have good jobs, higher incomes and private health care. They are going to religious services because they are getting something they value out of it.

That I find fascinating, as one almost instinctively presumes an either/or between the “secular university” and faith.

Richard Dawkins, twenty years after The God Delusion, sounds particularly out of touch:

A few weeks ago, I called Mr. Dawkins, the famous atheist whose book had so shaken me all those years ago. … He remained hopeful that secularism can replace religion. “It seems to me, should be reasonably easy to sort out,” he said. For ethics, he encouraged people to take civics classes and host a weekly discussion club. For community? “Play golf.”

He said he understood that churches in particular could provide moral instruction (and he said he valued the ethical teachings of Jesus as a man). But he insisted people should be able to fulfill their spiritual desires outside of faith: “It should be quite easy to show documentary films: David Attenborough films, Carl Sagan films, Neil deGrasse Tyson. There are lots of substitutes to spirituality that those can provide.”

But many of the people I have spoken to say those kinds of alternatives aren’t enough.

In a country where most people are pessimistic about the future and don’t trust the government, where hope is hard to come by, people are longing to believe in something. Religion can offer beliefs, belonging and behaviors all in one place; it can enchant life; most importantly, it tells people that their lives have a purpose.

It is either laughable or depressing (or both) to think a quality nature documentary could replace what religion has been doing for millennia. If only David Attenborough films could sufficiently answer the core dread of nonexistence and eternal separation from the people we love more than ourselves. If only Carl Sagan provided any actual relief from the unrelenting judgments of daily existence. If only golf was free! (And not boring, sorry!! (Though golfers might say the same about church.))

As Jackson puts it, people want to belong to “richer, more robust communities, ones that wrestle with hard questions about how to live.” People are looking not just to prolong life on planet earth, but to contemplate life, what gives it meaning. They’re interested in “confession, atonement, forgiveness, grace and redemption.”

3. One avenue not [yet] explored in Jackson’s reporting is how exhausting doubt is. How tiresome it is to question everything. On her Substack, the young writer Freya India argues that Gen Z hasn’t lost their faith — they just never learned it to begin with:

We question everything. We doubt what it means to live, what it means to love, what it means to be a good person, why any of that matters. Nothing is certain. And so, no, we aren’t so much in doubt as to whether we will live tomorrow, but whether there is any point to.

What is it like, to grow up this way? It’s hard to do justice to it. It’s a feeling of constant confusion and indecision. Never knowing the right choice, always unsure of ourselves, checking with others over and over. Immediate distrust of everyone. Suspicious of anything good; hardly surprised by hurt. … It is draining, exhausting, to exist in disbelief. […]

This is a generation that doesn’t understand how to have faith, never learnt the habit. And adults shrug this off because they think this is simply doubting the existence of God, but no, this is more than that, this is doubting good. This is not just a lack of faith in religion; this is a lack of faith in right and wrong. More and more of us doubting morality, seeing no benefit to being a better person, because why, what does it matter?

She argues — upsettingly, yet convincingly — that surveillance capitalism exploits our doubts. Tech platforms require our uncertainty to keep us coming back to them for answers that never really do come. “Dating apps,” for example, “help us find the one while making us doubt they will ever be enough.” A.I. is the ultimate case in point, relying on a doubt that we can write/think for ourselves — the machine can give us the right answer … right??

We have this delusion that doubt keeps us safe, somehow. … We doubt because to have faith would be terrifying. […] The truth is, doubt is far more restrictive than faith. Those without faith can’t be selfless or decisive or sacrifice, because they can’t commit to anything, not fully. They are suspended in doubt. And maybe doubting everything and everyone means you don’t get betrayed as badly or walked all over, but you also can’t be good, can’t be generous, can’t be grateful, can’t be patient, can’t love or fully be loved, because doubt gets in the way of doing anything real. …

And we have to ask ourselves, who is it we admire? Who do we want to be? Does anybody really admire doubtful people, or love stories of hesitancy and holding back, yet that’s exactly what we encourage? … What is life, if not risk and courage when you have reasons to hold back? In romantic relationships you don’t commit when there are no obstacles, you commit because there are obstacles, because anything that lasts a long time will come with reasons to leave, because we are all hard to love, you commit to kill the doubt and start the adventure. […]

We live in a world of strangers, with so few expectations. Our ancestors put customs and traditions and reminders in place because they knew how hard it is to be selfless, to commit to other people. Now some of us are trying it for the first time in our twenties and it feels terrifying. … What, the children who grew up on graphic online porn are suddenly going to know how to love someone for life? What, the generation taught to always put their freedom first are suddenly going to be great spouses, not feel terrified and trapped and restricted? What, the generation raised to swipe through each other like objects, consume each other’s lives like content, that won’t affect their character at all? Their ability to love? … Maybe the real nightmare is not that we won’t find someone loyal but we will discover, one day, with horror, that we are only capable of being loyal to ourselves.

I mean … damn. Take notes, people! And/or read Freya’s whole post. And/or listen to this new Arcade Fire song: “Always nervous with the real thing …”

4. In humor, McSweeney’s gave us a list for the ages. Funny, clever, and actually rather sweet, here is an excerpt of “The Elementary School Disciplinary Record of Jesus Christ,” by Amanda Lehr:

“Chews gum during class. Once, when I asked if he’d ‘brought enough for the whole class,’ Jesus pulled the wad from his mouth, broke it into many pieces, and gave it to his little friends. Then, everyone was chewing gum. He knew that’s not what I meant.”

“Keeps washing his classmates’ feet. It is very cute, but the floor is soaked. I slipped and nearly broke my neck.” …

“Failing math. Can multiply seventy by seven, but is adamant that the number three is the same as the number one. Consider screening for dyscalculia.”

“Keeps bringing his pet bird to school. I don’t care if it’s a dove. It’s not hygienic.”

“Turned in a very confusing family tree project. Accordion-folded, so when I opened it, the ‘begets’ rolled all the way out to the parking lot. At the end, the father’s branch was labeled NOT MY REAL DAD. Problems at home?” …

“Truancy. Wandered off in the middle of the day to go teach at the temple, which is rich. Maybe he can try passing a class here first.”

“Fermented all the juice boxes during snack time. I can’t prove it. But I know he did it.”

Also, from Little Old Lady Comedy, here are some humorous dialogues reimagining Jesus’ ministry in 2025; Judas, of course, would have heartburn. (Almost as good as The Man Who Met God in a Bar.) And for those who, like me, are taking about twelve antihistamines daily, The Onion offers Tips for Managing Seasonal Allergies: “Consider alternatives to breathing.”

5. Mockingbird director David Zahl’s new book The Big Relief comes out NEXT WEEK: TUESDAY! If you haven’t gotten your copy, pre-order any which way. Already some great reviews are coming in, this one by Chad Bird at 1517:

From past experience, I know that when a book by Dave Zahl comes knocking, there’s only one rational response: set aside all other books (classics included), turn off my phone, lock the door, put the dog outside, grab five yellow highlighters, and settle in for a literary and Gospel feast.

Zahl serves up gracious relief in every chapter. But what is grace?

“Grace is one-way love,” he writes. “Grace is a gift with no strings attached. It is noncontingent, a compassionate alliance, unmerited favor, sacrificial love that seeks a person out at their most unlovable.”

And in Christian terms, this grace is “revealed in — and inextricably tied to — the person and work of Jesus Christ.”

In fact, “Grace is the Big Relief at the heart of Christianity.” The church is not, or at least should not and must not be, a “purveyor of spiritual and moral burdens.” As if we don’t already labor under enough of those! As Zahl writes in this memorable line, “If you conceive of institutional Christianity as a burning building, and you have time to rescue only one item before the edifice collapses, grace is what I would grab every time.” 

Add to that a great review by Jon M. Sweeney at Spirituality and Practice.

6. I would be remiss, of course, to not mention the late Pope Francis, who died this week. Lots of lovely tributes, but for my pick, here’s one by novelist/veteran Phil Klay, in Vanity Fair:

The first pope from the Americas, he became what many referred to as the People’s Pontiff. He declined to take up residence in the Apostolic Palace. He carried his own bags. He ritually washed the feet of prisoners. He created a retreat for homeless Romans just steps from the Vatican. He declared a theme for his papacy — misericordia, meaning: mercy.

Archbishop Victor Manuel Fernàndez [said]: “Francis wrote to me that the best way to care for the doctrine of the faith is to grow our understanding of it, because ‘this harmonious growth will preserve Christian doctrine more effectively than any control mechanism,’ especially if we know how to present a God who loves, who frees, who lifts up, who empowers people.”

It’s this promise I held on to, throughout his papacy. The notion that, rather than tamp down discussions, the Church could be a place for harmonious growth.

7. Finally, Aidan Kimel at Eclectic Orthodoxy shared some excerpts from David Bentley Hart’s 2004 book The Beauty of the Infinite. Here, Hart reflects on the “inverted” nature of God’s vision, a vision that Pope Francis surely would have resonated with. Skimmers, prepare yourselves: all of the following is only four [partial] sentences.

In the light of Christ, Hart says,

God judges the visible orders of the world, subjects them to a new and intense radiance that pierces all the trappings and beguilements of power; a murdered slave is the eternal Word of the Father, whom the Father vindicates and makes victorious, and is the supreme rhetoric that unveils the squalor and deceits of the rhetoric of violence.

The scale of the reversal cannot be exaggerated: when Jesus stands before Pilate for the last time, beaten, derided, robed in purple and crowned with thorns, he must seem, from the vantage of all the noble wisdom of the empire and the age, merely absurd, a ridiculous figure prating incomprehensibly of an otherworldly kingdom and some undefined truth, obviously mad, oblivious of the lowliness of his state and of the magnitude of the powers into whose hands he has been delivered. But in the light of the resurrection, from the perspective of Christianity’s inverted order of vision, the mockery now redounds upon all kings and emperors, whose finery and symbols of status are revealed to be nothing more than rags and brambles beside the majesty of God’s Son, beside this servile shape in which God displays his infinite power to be where he will be; all the rulers of the earth cannot begin to surpass in grandeur this beauty of the God who ventures forth to make even the dust his glory.

There is a special Christian humor here, a special kind of Christian irreverence: in Rome the emperor is now as nothing …

Strays: 

@brunchwithbabs 🍽  Did your Mom ever teach you the Do’s and Don’ts for loading the dishwasher?  In our family, when it comes to chores, how to load the dishwasher is one of the hottest topics.  Let’s face it, everyone has their own system that they think is the only way to load the dishwasher.  Well, Babs’ is here to teach you the proper way to load your dishwasher so that each and every dish comes out sparkling clean.  🍽 Xo Babs #dishwasher #howtoloadadishwasher ♬ original sound – Babs

subscribe to the Mockingbird newsletter

COMMENTS


2 responses to “April 19-25”

  1. Andrew of MO says:

    The Dawkins comment reminds me of Carl Sagan talking about how science is a great source for spirituality. One commentator suggested that no one was likely to quote Einstein at a funeral.

    In a similar vein, when Daniel Dennett died last year, I offered a reflection about him, based on what I understood his view of consciousness to be.

    Daniel Dennett died. Well, that is not entirely accurate. According to my understanding of Dennett’s philosophy, “Daniel Dennett” did not die, because “Daniel Dennett” did not exist in the first place. He was a collection of uncomprehending competences that produced the illusion of consciousness that could be referred to as “Daniel Dennett.” I am sure his family will be relieved.

  2. […] Last month it was the right way to load dishwashers; this month, according to NewsThump it’s taking out the […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *