TV

Pulling a Black Rabbit Out of the Hat

A Unlikely Story of Prodigal Brothers

Blake Nail / 11.10.25

It’s difficult to accurately trace down the roots. Some say it was Louis Comte in 1814 and others say it was perfected by John Henry Anderson in the mid-1800s. And by “some” and “others” I mean Wikipedia, of course. Sources on the origin of the hat trick are slim but either way, at some point, a hand reached into the darkness of a top hat and pulled out a white rabbit, changing the world forever. Since then, magicians have been following suit as commoners like myself appropriate the saying to describe impossible situations in our everyday lives. Albeit cliche, the trick signifies magic in the common vernacular.

Something about the white rabbit resonates with us. We’ve always associated a symbolic meaning to colors. White is typically associated with innocence, purity, or newness. A traditional white wedding dress. Brand-new all-white shoes are deemed “fresh” and protected with extra care. A clean sheet of white paper is the start of something new. The plea for mercy and momentary innocence in a white flag waving surrender. And conversely, we have darkness. The black sheep of the family. A black cat on Halloween. The darkness of the world which light shines into. It bears a sense of otherness, strangeness and stained ungodliness. The magic wouldn’t pop if a black rabbit were pulled out of the dark abyss contained in a top hat. And yet it’s the very trick performed in Black Rabbit.

Black Rabbit is one of the numerous shows being pumped out on the streaming services, Netflix to be specific. Praise God for limited series. It is a grace given for those of us who can no longer keep up with seasonal shows. I’ve run out of room in my brain to remember and keep track of previous season storylines from what feels like seven years past. It’s hard enough keeping track of my own life happenings, much less fictional characters. If this is a sentiment you share, this fast-paced, intense, eight-episode ride might be a good fit for you.

The story of Black Rabbit is one of unresolved trauma, foolish decisions, new levels of self-serving behavior and the unbreakable bond between brothers. Those of us with siblings are well aware of the union that develops when you’ve shared a childhood together. I have two brothers myself and the memories we hold will forever bind us in this life. And yet, childhood can also leave you with resentments and trauma tucked away somewhere unseen. The Friedken brothers find themselves riddled with the aftershocks of their painful childhood. How they deal with it is not unfamiliar to us either.

Jake Friedken, played by Jude Law, is responsible, respected, runs a popular New York restaurant, and by all accounts seems to be a good father. Vince, on the other hand, played by Jason Bateman, is a degenerate gambler, drug abuser, and a bet away his inheritance. After fleeing town with a mess behind him, Vince has shown up in Jake’s life once again, years later.

Everyone has the friend or family member who’s a disruptive bomb to your life. The one person who, when the phone starts ringing and you see their name, you know your day is about to change. And if you don’t have a person like that in your life … well, some dots may need connecting. After a phone call from Vince about his upcoming arrival, Jake’s life starts to spiral downward. Problem after problem arise as Vince’s choices radically affect the brothers’ lives and eventually put those lives on the line. But as Vince and Jake rub shoulders, true characters are revealed. Jake, the one who seemingly ordered his life properly, is not who we think he is. He’s only out for himself, a financial fraud who is actually, surprise surprise, not father of the year. In other words, he’s like the rest of us.

How often are the people we deem as problematic and unruly to deal with the catalysts who unveil the crookedness within ourselves. They serve as a mirror to everything we’ve been able to tuck away from the surface. We find ourselves in the temple praying the words “Lord, thank you I’m not like …” only to realize we’ve missed the point.

Long before there were streaming services, there was a Messiah telling unsettling parables. And one quite similar to Black Rabbit. Jesus tells a parable we call the Prodigal Son about two brothers both in need of God’s grace. One, the Elder, is a religious and morally upright son. The other, the Younger, is a rebellious sinner lost in the world. When the younger brother comes home, trouble arises for the Elder as his facade of togetherness falls apart.

What Black Rabbit reveals, as we see in life and Christ’s parable, is the Elder brother (those of us who “have it together”) may stand firm in our appearances, but underneath something vicious hides. Our cover gets blown, our ugliness and sinfulness uncovered for all to see. Or perhaps you relate to the younger brother, burdened and heavy-laden by the oppressive awareness of your wayward proclivities. You’ve been whispered about, pointed at, and shamed. The Friedken brothers provide a glimpse into both these notorious archetypes.

But there’s hope.

Near the end of the show, we see the brothers a little clearer as their past is fully shown to us: a shared father who abused their mother. One night, Vince has seen enough and with a choice object, kills his father. To Vince’s knowledge, this is a family secret carried between his mother and himself his whole life, a burden he has shouldered all alone while being cast as the black sheep of the family. He is far from Christ morally, but in his bearing of burdens he’s picked up his cross, suffering a lonely, misunderstood life. “Younger brothers” are way more acquainted with the grace and mercy of our good God than us “elder brothers.” And thus in the end, even though Jake is evenly as culpable and deserving of just wrath, Vince sacrificially offers his life to once again bear the burden for his brother. To give him a new life.

Director Ben Semanoff, previously a magician, sees his past employment influencing his filmmaking. When asked if there was a correlation between the two in his evolution as a director, he responded:

Without a doubt, every little bit of development … I think it all circles a theme of this belief that anything is sort of feasible, and you just have to solve a problem, and what’s the problem? And storytelling is really that. So much of storytelling is what is the challenge in front of us, and how do we solve it? But it’s also about misdirecting, so that there can be a really wonderful surprise later … That’s where the magic comes into it, right?

And Ben solves the challenge well by pulling not a white, pure, and innocent rabbit out of his hat but rather the ungodly, sinner, black rabbit that is Vince. His sacrificial offer of his own life on behalf of all parties involved leads to new life for Jake who, although guilty and liable to the law, is by all appearances off scot-free. Sure, he’s lost his restaurant, the girl he was chasing, and his own brother, but he’s redeemed. He’s been humbled. Shed of his regal, flashy appearance paired with unnecessary bravado, he’s at the bottom once again. No longer a big time New York restaurant owner but rather a regular Joe Schmo server at a small cafe. Black rabbit Vince may be, marred and stained by the world and his actions in it, his death indeed gave life. There was magic in it. And it leaves me wondering, if so much so with Vince, a degenerate Christ, how much more when the rabbit ascends out of the darkness white as snow.

subscribe to the Mockingbird newsletter

COMMENTS


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *