Pardon’s the Word to All: Forgiving Billy Shakespeare

A stunning essay appeared on The Millions last week, Stephen Akey’s “Shakespeare as God,” which […]

David Zahl / 10.10.12

A stunning essay appeared on The Millions last week, Stephen Akey’s “Shakespeare as God,” which casts a light (pun intended) on a couple of The Bard’s lesser-known “late romances,” e.g. The Winter’s Tale and Cymbeline. Now, before you glaze over, know that I hadn’t read or seen them either. They are not exactly first on the syllabus of most Shakespeare survey classes. But Akey’s observations about the role that forgiveness plays in these later works are both surprising and penetrating, even if he stops a bit short of where we might. But Shakespeare’s words reach, as they always do, beyond the specific plot points and into more universal territory. He may not have been a “theologian”–at least no more than any other artist with such piercing vision–but some might say that universal insight/truth is necessarily religious, to some degree or another. That is, it is perhaps no coincidence that he would gravitate, toward the end of his life, to the heart of the matter:

Another curiosity about the romances is the degree to which they turn on the concept of forgiveness. “Pardon’s the word to all,” says Cymbeline late in the play of that title, jauntily brushing aside five acts worth of treachery, corruption, murder, and deceit. Was there something in Shakespeare’s experience that turned his thoughts in his last years to the possibility of forgiveness? Had his many years as an absent husband and father begun to gnaw at him as he contemplated retirement and a return to the wife and family he had clearly neglected? Or had his wife Anne – perhaps understandably in the light of their long separation – been “sluiced” in his absence, and had he, with all his attendant guilts and slippages, to pardon her for that? Was he thinking of the Catholicism he might secretly have been raised in and of the doctrine of grace that – it could be argued – subtly informs these plays? Or was it something simpler and even more personal – namely, brooding on the usual [screw-]ups that everyone racks up over time and hopes to be forgiven for? Virtually nothing is known of the man’s inner life, but few people dispute the semi-autobiographical nature of The Tempest, with its sense of a valediction to the theater he had known and loved. So why not extrapolate a little from the work to the life?

Depends on whose life, I guess. While I’m very much interested in Shakespeare’s life, I’m more interested in my own. What I extrapolate from The Winter’s Tale is that if Leontes deserves a break, so do I. There came a time in my life when I needed to be forgiven. I wasn’t. If I must take my consolation from a play rather than from any flesh and blood Hermione, that’s not quite so bleak as it sounds. Yes, I would have preferred real forgiveness to the literary kind, but I find it no small consolation that at the end of his life the world’s supreme imaginative writer returns again and again to a basic home truth: we must forgive each other. For me, reading Shakespeare is like going to church, except that in place of a God I could never and wouldn’t want to believe in, I “commune,” so to speak, with a mind that seems to comprehend all others and enforces no doctrinal obedience. This community of believers embraces anyone who has ever seen, heard, or read a word of Shakespeare’s and been moved to wonder and reflection. That’s what I call a catholic church.

The forgiveness I’ve spoken of is not without cost. Antigonus and Mamillius die, and when Hermione steps off that pedestal, she speaks to her daughter, not to her husband. Part fairly tale, part moral exemplum, The Winter’s Tale is what religion would be if it could free itself of those hectoring, incomprehensible Gods. In the unveiling of the supposed “miracle” in Act V, the sage and long-suffering Paulina speaks the lines that could serve as the epitaph for all of late Shakespeare: “It is required / You do awake your faith.”



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.