Good News for Victimizers

Divine grace is mercy to the undeserving, because if we deserved it then it wouldn’t be mercy.

Alan Jacobs / 10.9.24

An especially powerful moment in the movie Good Will Hunting (1997) comes when Dr. Sean Maguire (Robin Williams) finally, after many unsuccessful attempts, gets through to Will by telling him, “It’s not your fault.” And again: “It’s not your fault.” And again and again and again: “It’s not your fault.” — however many times it takes until Will finally accepts the truth of the statement: that the sexual abuse he suffered as a child was not because of anything he did or said or was or is. Will’s inchoate sense of guilt is, in this moment, dissolved, and he, in turn, dissolves in tears. He is liberated, and rightly liberated, from false guilt.

As I say, it’s a really powerful scene. Whenever I see it, though, I think: But what about those of us who are at fault? What does Dr. Maguire have to say to us?

To be clear, I haven’t sexually abused anyone, ever; nor have I been the victim of sexual abuse. I could tell you some true stories, though, about things my father did to me … but no. I don’t want to go there, because I think it’s bad for me to do so, and bad in multiple ways. For one thing, to dwell on these things encourages me to be uncharitable to my father, may he rest in peace — and I mean that seriously, May he rest in peace.

But, more important, it encourages me to be excessively charitable — that is to say, inappropriately indulgent — to myself. Too often over the years I have been impatient and angry with my wife and son, and when I recall my father’s impatience and anger with me, I find myself all-too-ready to construct a narrative in which I am the nearly helpless victim of my past. “Daddy set the example. I learned that pattern from my earliest days, and in times of stress I merely repeat it” — which is, if not a “Get out of jail free” card, a “Get out of jail after a reduced sentence due to extenuating circumstances” card. And I understand myself well enough to know that I will grab that card every time if it is offered to me.

And when I grab that card, my theology is going wrong — going tragically wrong.

If I can think of myself, not as an innocent perhaps, but as a victim as well as a victimizer — as someone who may be, as King Lear famously said, “more sinned against than sinning” — or even if not that then at least “sinned against before I did any sinning” — then in my mind I move myself a few places ahead in the queue of moral and spiritual quality. Now, to be sure, I remain a “miserable offender,” which literally means a sinner in need of mercy: Miserere mei Domine = “Have mercy on me, O Lord.”  But I don’t need mercy quite as desperately as (to choose a totally random example) my father does.

Divine grace is mercy to the undeserving, because if we deserved it then it wouldn’t be mercy. But in my secret mind and heart I will always construct a spiritual spreadsheet in which I am less undeserving than others. And I believe it would be better that I not think of my father at all than to think of him only to congratulate myself on my spiritual superiority.

One of the very best things that a church can do is to bind up the wounds of those who have been damaged by their families, and indeed by their church families. Nothing is more beautiful and more Christlike than a church that utters to broken-hearted people the Comfortable Words of our Savior and makes those words real and effectual in their lives.

But when Jesus says, “Come to me, all who labor and are heavy laden, and I will give you rest” (Mt. 11:28), that is Good News not just for the victims but also for the victimizers, who “labor and are heavy laden” because of their anger, their belligerence, their violence — all those sins that don’t just wound the victims but also press the victimizers’ faces to the dirt. As the old General Confession says, the memory of our sins “is grievous unto us; the burden of them is intolerable” — that is, too heavy for us to bear. We are broken under the load. And only One can lift that load from our backs.

Sometimes we have fits of compassion for the victimizers and abusers, and often that takes the form of seeing them as victims themselves, of their own abusive parents or churches — and that generation was in turn victimized, and the one before it, and the one before that, and on we go in a race all the way back to Adam, whose First Sin is no more explicable to us than our own shortcomings. (Remember the old meme Thanks, Obama? This one is Thanks, Adam.) Or, if you don’t want to go that far back, you can do as Elvis Costello suggests and “Blame It On Cain”: “It’s nobody’s fault / But we need somebody to burn.”

Either way, it’s a pointless chase.

Suppose that the one who victimized me was not himself a victim. Suppose that he was raised by thoughtful and sensitive saints, who always did exactly the right thing, struck precisely the correct note, never erred through severity or laxity or indifference — but still he sinned, and sinned grossly. In that case his situation before Jesus Christ would be … in no way different than my own. In no way whatsoever.

Sean Maguire says to Will Hunting, “It’s not your fault.” Jesus Christ says to you, and to me, and to all who turn to him, “It is your fault. And I forgive you. And nothing you do can separate you from my love.” Both men bring good news. Which of them brings better news?

subscribe to the Mockingbird newsletter

COMMENTS


2 responses to “Good News for Victimizers”

  1. I’m reminded of another meme–the little girl saying, “Why not both?”
    Mercy to the victims? YES. Mercy to the victimizers? YES. So much yes to all of this. And I guess a lot of what I’m thinking about depends on what it means to “dwell on” something. Is therapy “dwelling on” the past? Because one of the gifts of therapy (in a sense, dwelling on the past by confronting it) to me has been understanding my reactions based on events I experienced. In that sense, grace has been exceedingly kind in excavating the “old” in order to replace it with the “new” (behold, I make ALL things new!)–the very real work of rewiring neurological pathways, etc, so that my reactions (ie, dealing with my kids) don’t have to mirror the past. I don’t think this has to veer into self-pity or indulgence; it can be a kindness of God to meet me where I am.

  2. Aubrey says:

    This reminds me of an interview I heard where singer Granger Smith talks about the drowning of his son in their backyard pool. This event almost triggered his suicide. Maybe people, well meaning people, kept saying this wasn’t your fault, this wasn’t your fault. But he said that, in a sense it was his fault. As sinners, which we all are, even mistakes or ignorance can be counted as sin. And it wasn’t until he accepted that that he was able to see the Grace of God in a real way that gave him a fresh perspective on his Christianity, which helped him move forward in his healing. This in turn helped me better process my sister’s death and other brokenness in my life. I am absolved of sin but only through Christ who truly covers me.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *