Evil Reigns Only For a Time

A Midsummer Night’s Scream: No Country for Old Men

Ian Olson / 8.22.25

Howdy, friendos. We four (Ian, Blake, Blaine, and Caleb) are back to discuss the Coen brothers’ masterpiece No Country for Old Men, which is perhaps not a classic horror film but is certainly among the tensest and most frightening I’ve ever seen. Much profundity and tears await, so come join us!

Blaine: There’s a quote from The Wailing that bridges the gap between these two movies quite nicely: “Not everything that moves, breathes, and talks is alive.”

It reminds me of this scene in The Inferno where Dante encounters this shade whom he recognizes as being alive and well on earth. The shade tells him that it’s not uncommon for a soul to be in hell, leaving the body to be replaced by a demon on earth. And that’s the topic that has been burning a hole in my pocket for us to discuss together — Anton Chigurh as a ghost/spirit/demon.

It’s a motif that the book plays up more than the movie (if memory serves), but there are plenty of lines that refer to Chigurh as a ghost or someone who’s not there: “Do you see me?”

Ian: “He’s sort of a ghost,” I think Wells says, which Llewelyn denies, but even in action there’s an invisibility that surrounds and protects him. I think that even the car accident at the end shows up that invisibility, and even after taking the kid’s shirt he says, “You never saw me.”

I’m also chuffed that we watched this after The Wailing, as the motif of the Fool was back in strength.

Blaine: Yes! And it feels like one of the key scenes here is when Sheriff Bell goes back to the motel where Llewelyn was killed and stands outside the door, staring into the blown-off bolt hole. We get a POV shot from Bell as he stares into that shiny brass, and it sure looks like he/we see shadows. Is it his/our own, or a specter? The countershot to this is a crazed Chigurh on the other side of the doorway, face half lit, half covered in shadow. And of course, when Bell opens the door … no one is there.

Ian: Yes! This is the first time I’ve seen it where I thought, “WAIT A MINUTE! HE DIDN’T JUST SLIP OUT!” He vanished. He’s someone who’s not there on a floor that’s not there, either. Wells counted the floors from outside: “One’s missing.”

I think Chigurh is real but inexplicable and a symptom of the contemporary world’s downward spiral, but also simultaneously a symptom of the evil that has always been present. I think it has just not always been so nakedly pervasive. I think that’s in line with Bell and the El Paso sheriff’s senses that things are different as well as with Ellis’ correction at the end (i.e., “This has always been here”). Dialectically. And this informs Bell’s dream at the end.

Blaine: I’ll say off the bat that I tend to read Sheriff Bell’s dream through the lens of McCarthy’s books, which may not be the best. Or it may be. Who knows?

The big thing for me about the second dream is that the father is “carrying the fire.” This phrase “carrying the fire” is a big deal in McCarthy’s work. It’s a central idea in The Road, and you see it in Blood Meridian too. I tend to read it as shorthand for God, Hope, Virtue, etc. (You name it — depends on how the day is going.) So, “Carrying the fire” in “all that dark” is the presence of the divine in a world gone wrong.

And then there are his final words: “Then I woke up”:

  1. Either the realization that you have to face the darkness, but there’s hope, or
  2. The loss of faith. It was just a dream.

That’s a vast oversimplification, but it’ll have to do for now.

Ian: It’ll do ‘til the complication gets here.

Blaine: But it also works with the first dream, which I think we all (myself foremost) ignore too much: “I think I lost it.”

Ian: This is the first time I’ve watched this where “And he’s waiting for me” didn’t strike me as ominous. I think I heard “The way they would in old times” differently this viewing, as the goodness of old times is revered and lamented here. His dad’s preparing a fire ahead “in all that dark and all that cold.”

Blaine: Well, Ian, what you just said hit me like a ton of bricks. Considering I have daddy issues too, it’s astounding this never occurred to me.

Blake: I guess considering I don’t have the same daddy issues, I never read it as anything but comforting — hence why I was struggling tying your reading with that dream.

Blaine: I actually have a pit in my stomach right now just thinking about the way you’ve heard that line. Bessel van der Kolk would be proud.

Blake: Especially if we read the carrying of fire as virtue, good, divine, etc. then I always presumed it had to be comforting.

Blaine: Yeah, this is my inclination as well, but “And then I woke up” haunts me.

Blake: Though a comfort that one arrives at by going THROUGH the dark and cold, not around.

Ian: That’s exactly right. But you’re not alone. Dad’s gone on ahead.

Blake: And Blaine, I take that as the faithlessness of man. Of course, we sense the divine, but then we wake up. And what happens when we wake up? We often forget. This has been the project of “the world” from the beginning — to extinguish the fire forever. For us to be fully “awakened.”

Blaine: Yeah, it’s just that the forgetting is real scurry to me.

Blake: But that’s where hope comes in. The divine can’t be extinguished. Just like we don’t always forget our dreams.

Blaine:  LET ME BE SCARED. DON’T “BE NOT AFRAID” MY SAD BOI ENERGY.

Blake: Oh. If you aren’t still, something is wrong. We still live in an awakened world. The aim to extinguish the light should always frighten us. But to call forth some True Detective, the light can be oh so small … but it seems to me it’s still winning. Evil reigns for a time, but eternity is not in its grasp.

Ian: It is haunting, but this time around I feel like it loops back to “A man would have to say, ‘Ok. I’ll be a part of this world.’”

Blake: To stare down the abyss and say ok, I’ll lay down my life for good. That line haunts my everyday.

Ian: Isn’t it also a symptom of that spiral that some of us hear about Sheriff Bell’s dad going on ahead and we felt dread or can’t connect that to our experiences with our dads?

Blake: Very much so.

Blaine: “The falcon cannot hear the falconer.” Also, the look Loretta gives him when he finishes his dream. That’s how I feel like it must be being married to me.

Blake: I think I largely align with Chigurh being real, but a Michael Myers type of other. Of this world, but not quite.

Blaine: I think Chigurh is the exact same thing the Japanese man is in The Wailing.

Blake: A DEMON? A DEVIL? A FOREIGNER?

Blaine: Yeah. “Not everything that moves, breaths, and talks is alive.” I’m of two minds every time I watch this motion picture. Mind One thinks about the stuff we’re discussing, and Mind Two sits back, breathless at such a remarkable evocation of place, space, and time.

Blake: Oh, for sure. I think this film is gorgeous. I feel like we need to talk at some point about Kelly Macdonald refusing to call it. Because that’s the only way his game could be beat. By forcing him to choose. And I think that feeds into him being the Devil since he is primarily tempter, not necessarily act-er.

Blaine: I always want to think that he doesn’t kill her, but then he looks at his boots before he leaves the house.

Blake: Same. But I think it’s cheap hope.

Ian: I did for a long time too, but like you’re saying, the film’s semiotics mean he’s killed her.

Blake: I also think that feeds into him being the Devil since he is both chaos and hound on a trail. He kills both randomly and with relentless aim. But I also don’t want to tie him too closely to the Devil as I like Ian’s statement about evil’s pervasiveness being more distinct now. I think he is a mortal who has bargained with the wrong deity. He is Faustus. He doesn’t even play by his own game as he kills without giving the victim a chance to “call it.”

Blake: I think there is parallelism between Chigurh and the Japanese man as there is between Jong-Goo and Llewelyn: unholy fools who are utterly likable. And we mourn their story ending.

Blaine: There are so many fun visual references to Chigurh as a ghost or specter that haunts the Southwest. Cats are important when they show up. The cat at the Eagle Pass hotel could sense the impending danger and survived. Bell’s friend is safe out there in the country because he’s surrounded by all these cats.

Blake: What does he say about his cats? I forget. It’s hilarious whatever it is.

Blaine: Something about “depends on what you mean by have.” It’s interesting that No Country draws so many parallels between Llewelyn and Chigurh: both get shot, both buy a shirt off a passerby, both are hunters, and they have similar weapon choices (multiple times).

Blake: One might even go so far as to say Chigurh might be the physical manifestation of the consequences of all of Llewelyn’s idiocy. In a sense they are two sides of the same coin.

Blaine: If Chigurh is fate, Llewelyn is Sisyphus, thinking he can control fate and cheat death.

Blake: Caleb’s been kind of quiet — he’s probably doing ministery things.

Caleb: Indeed, fellas. I’ve been preparing for a funeral.

I echo the sentiment that the end dream speech is hopeful — that there is a good light on the horizon, almost inexplicably.

When Llewelyn is first gathering the money in the beginning, a storm is forming. But we really only see the lightning when he goes back to give water to that dying man. That’s where enlightenment is. In mercy.

It may be “dumber than hell” he tells his wife, “but I’m going to do it.” And of course, that’s the begging of the end for him. He flees from his pursuers INTO the lightning. This is no country for good men, either. But whoever offers a cup of water in my name will, by no means, lose his reward.

Ian: The offering of cold water was not lost on me either, Caleb.

Blaine: I would also like to add that I was grateful for the opportunity to watch this film again. This was an emotional viewing for me, as so much reminded me of my grandfather, who recently died — of watching it with him; how the characters talk the way he talked; the driving (my grandfather being a West Texas oil man); the way, when I showed him the movie for the first time, he waited until it was almost over to tell me that he knew Tommy Lee Jones.

And then the father going on ahead to make a fire in all that dark — I felt viscerally the hope of that dream this time around.

Ian: Grimes power move: “Yep, I know that feller.” That’s so moving, Blaine. I feel it’s poignance all the more in light of my grandpa’s death this past week. And I want to assure you and everyone else that there is a country for old men, for anyone who will have it, where every sad thing comes untrue, where the Father is waiting for us, with a roaring fire and a rich banquet.

That’s all for this week, folks, but get ready for next week by watching Pulse (2001). We’ll see you in a few!

subscribe to the Mockingbird newsletter

COMMENTS


One response to “Evil Reigns Only For a Time”

  1. Nate Mills says:

    Really enjoyed this discussion. Fantastic insights into a truly remarkable film. If I recall correctly, McCarthy began the film as a screenplay before pivoting the story into a standalone novel. The Coen Brothers joked that when adapting it for the screen one brother read aloud while the other brother typed. Much of the dialogue, including the famous monologues of Sheriff Bell are essentially borrowed verbatim.

    Barry Corbin (Ellis) gives an interesting interview on his experience filming here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d8zG3QsZehM&ab_channel=TTFTShow

    In the book, the line about God coming into his life comes from Ellis rather than Bell. The absence of Bell’s WW2 history was also a conspicuous omission. Tommy Lee-Jones certainly had the chops to deliver those monologues.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *