Another Week Ends

Zadie Smith’s Radical Humanism, New George Harrison, and Gen Z’s Social Media Lament

1. Where to even begin with Ezra Klein’s recent Zadie Smith interview? There are enough highlightable moments that if I pasted them all here I’d be basically sharing the entire thing. Smith is an essayist and novelist with seemingly endless off-the-cuff insights and a singular open-heartedness. In the interview she discusses everything from the totalizing effects of technology to the fundamentals of what it means to be a human being:

I would say that most of our experiences of ourselves are quite deeply irrational. If you stop a couple in the street and say to them, why are you married? You are not going to get a rational answer from them. You’re going to get murmurings, some sentimental, some partially logical, some apologetic, some unsure. But there’s a large area of our intimate lives, some of our most serious decisions, which can’t be presented to logic in that way. I think you have to allow people an area of self that doesn’t submit to a mathematical program.

When it comes to the fraught territory of language — what’s called “wokeness” or “word policing” — here Smith offers a perspective that I, at least, had not considered. More compassionate, for starters.

I don’t blame anyone for the linguistic turn. It was a linguistic turn mostly on the part of young people. But how can you blame them? Given that they had no money, really, no tools, very little physical, material freedoms in the world, it seems natural to me that they fought in the only place they knew where to fight, which was language. The actual means of production are out of their hands. They were enveloped by this technological revolution, which basically kind of owned them. It doesn’t surprise me that the battleground ended up being language. Because language is the thing that’s right in front of you. You can do something about it. You can’t really do anything about late capitalism, or you didn’t feel like you could in 2012. You felt trapped.

So it doesn’t surprise me, but it’s wildly inefficient. It’s not good enough. I’m always happy that people use the “right” words around me and others. But it’s nothing compared to decent wages, decent housing, health care, human rights. So it’s not that I think it’s worthless. But to have it so wildly overburdened with meaning and power is a kind of trick that was played on us.

As for other tricks being played on us? Life online generally:

The humans I know and love, this machinery is not worthy of them. That’s the best way I can put it… [The internet is] about capture. All mediums in the past have had partial capture. What blows my mind and what I think is the paradigm shift is, this is total. When I get on a train in the morning and I look down a carriage, there isn’t a single person who is looking up from their phones. … I know that the internet is a culture and it’s joyful to so many people… and there’s been delight all over it, just as there was delight in television for me. But the political consequences are clear.

And when you see your loved ones caught up in “this machinery”:

It’s important to be a bit more forgiving when they’re being those people online. I see that too — people I love, I see them online, and I’m like, who are you? This is not the same person I hang out with. This is a different person. But it’s really important to take the responsibility and the blame off individuals. It’s a behavior modification system. It’s meant to do that. […]

Technologies aren’t neutral. They are a philosophy and an ideology. The technology of these algorithms is the idea that everything in the world can get classified. And that’s not just a practical matter. That’s a philosophy — that there’s nothing in the world that cannot be organized, classified and labeled. And I just don’t believe that.

Contra technology’s classification-organization ideology, Smith calls herself a “radical humanist”:

It means you don’t ever dismiss people. You don’t ever call them trash. You don’t ever think that they are boring or limited. You think that they are infinite. They may not be to your taste, fair play. But as I heard Elizabeth Strout saying somewhere recently, every person is a world […]

I think there is a deep isolation in people. You can have 20 kids and you can get married four times, or you can be part of a great, massive chosen family of wonderful club kids or whatever it is, and there will be moments when you will feel this isolation. I think it’s existential. I think it’s a feeling of being lost in the world sometimes. I think people are super frightened of it and do anything to avoid feeling it.

Look also for her defense of marriage (the rare place in life where you don’t have to perform) and a critique of generational tensions (“the most delusional thing in contemporary discourse … You are literally fighting the person you’re about to become”).

2. Also in that interview, Smith talks winsomely about having no smartphone except for about three months in 2008. Why? Effectively, she says, it would destroy her life … as they have for pretty much everyone else. This week, it’s Jonathan Haidt bringing this evidence to bear with his New York Times  piece “Gen Z Has Regrets”. It’d be easy to read some of the following and think, yeahhh another prophet clanging pots in the wilderness. But Haidt is one of the more clear-eyed prophets you’ll encounter, and when he speaks, it’s worth tuning in. In this case, he and co-writer Will Johnson ask if young people wish social media had never existed. Between a third and a half say they do!

Nearly all American teenagers use social media regularly, and they spend an average of nearly five hours a day just on these platforms. … 52 percent of the total sample say social media has benefited their lives, and 29 percent say it has hurt them personally. … We have found this pattern — that social media disproportionately hurts young people from historically disadvantaged groups — in a wide array of surveys. […]

We’re not just talking about sad feelings from FOMO or social comparison. We’re talking about a range of documented risks that affect heavy users, including sleep deprivation, body image distortion, depression, anxiety, exposure to content promoting suicide and eating disorders, sexual predation and sextortion, and “problematic use,” which is the term psychologists use to describe compulsive overuse that interferes with success in other areas of life. If any other consumer product was causing serious harm to more than one out of every 10 of its young users, there would be a tidal wave of state and federal legislation to ban or regulate it.

In 2020 Sarah Condon reverberantly said, “We are in the 1920s of cigarettes when it comes to social media.” In 2024, the prognosis seems clear!

Haidt and Johnson then investigate the most regrettable online platforms; least regrettable included Netflix and YouTube.

Gen Z does not heavily regret the basic communication, storytelling and information-seeking functions of the internet. If smartphones merely let people text each other, watch movies and search for helpful information or interesting videos (without personalized recommendation algorithms intended to hook users), there would be far less regret and resentment. …

Many more respondents wished these products had never been invented: Instagram (34 percent), Facebook (37 percent), Snapchat (43 percent), and the most regretted platforms of all: TikTok (47 percent) and X/Twitter (50 percent).

3. At least there are some genuinely funny links this week. First, from the New Yorker: “Let’s Have a Long Talk About Our Relationship Just Before Bed!”: “Sweetie, are the ‘Clockwork Orange’ eyelid clamps comfy? Because I don’t want you to miss any part of the twelve-minute monologue I’ve recorded…” And from, as always, Reductress: “REPORT: Therapist Kind of Got Your Ass There”:

In a devastating report emerging from your bedroom where you’re currently on minute 15 of your zoom therapy session, your therapist just kind of got your ass. […]

“I don’t know how she did it,” you told reporters. “I guess with that degree of hers. Yeah, on second thought, this is the exact thing she studied. No clue why I didn’t expect her to put that education to use.”

For funny-and-on-point, this “Daily Itinerary for the Person I Am Not” perfectly illustrates the law of the person we wish we could be — that phantom tauntingly accompanying us at every step of the day.

8:30 a.m. The person I am not seamlessly merges onto the highway without getting anxious or silently farting the whole way and then parallel parks in one perfect move without her insides screaming, “being bad at this reflects poorly on all women.” […]

9:15 p.m. The person I am not reads Thoreau’s “Walden” before bed, as she does every night, just because it reminds her of that one summer she finished every book that a person needs to read to seem deep.

9:33 p.m. The person I am not flosses.

And finally, the last third of this standup had me in stitches about meditation apps:

4. At Plough James R. Wood shared an incredible personal essay about the draws and dangers of autonomy as an organizing principle, which is not at all disconnected from everything already covered above about unboundedness in daily existence. Throughout, he works to refine a definition of freedom:

I came to adopt a conception of freedom that had destroyed the lives of many around me, and which would threaten to destroy my own as well: the popular idea of freedom as unconstrained choice. Since this is impossible, the default was a more achievable version: the ability to drop commitments and relationships at any point when they become too complicated. Freedom as the license to leave when things get tough. Live by the mantra of Robert De Niro’s character in Heat: “Don’t let yourself get attached to anything you are not willing to walk out on in thirty seconds flat if you feel the heat around the corner.” If complications come, don’t worry. You can always go.

I eventually came to see that such freedom left me and some of those I loved unfree to love and to be known in love. Furthermore, this approach to freedom is a form of self-harm that also harms those dependent on you. […]

Children always complicate things – especially social theories that are fundamentally grounded in the autonomous individual. Children expose the lie that we are primarily individuals who only enter relationships voluntarily according to rational self-interest. The involuntary nature of the most important things in life can be experienced both for good or ill. No, we are not free to choose our parents, and that is a good thing: we do not choose to come into the world; our existence is the pure gift of our parents to us.

To quote Zadie Smith (again): “You can’t fight for a freedom you’ve forgotten how to identify.” In such territory, I tend to reach toward the hard-won, age-old wisdoms of religion which gave no small amount of consideration to these topics. Luckily, Wood goes straight there, unapologetically:

What I needed was not freedom from others, retaining an easy opt-out clause for every relationship. What I needed was a relationship with the one who is “nearer to me than I am to myself,” as Augustine said, and whose love frees me to know and be known by others, a freedom that leads to mutual service (Gal. 5). I needed freedom in fellowship, not freedom from commitment and obligation.

5. This documentary from Nicholas Ma (of Won’t You Be My Neighbor) looks great:

6. If someone ever tells me work is divine — actually, this comes up quite a bit in certain religious spheres! — I am skeptical. It usually turns out to be a ruse tied back to our economy to keep us working, religiously. But at the Atlantic this week Sara Tillinger Wolkenfeld, a scholar of ancient Jewish texts, makes a key distinction between two different kinds of work according to ancient Hebrew:

What Americans colloquially call “work” divides into two categories in ancient Hebrew. Melakhah connotes creative labor, according to early rabbinic commentaries on the biblical text. This is distinct from avodah, the word used to describe more menial toil, such as the work that the enslaved Israelites perform for their Egyptian taskmasters as described in the Book of Exodus. […]

The very act of Creation in which God produces the world using language is framed as a quintessential example of melakhah. “Let there be light” may seem as effortless to modern readers as “Abracadabra!” but Genesis categorizes this act as labor, noting, “God rested on the seventh day from all the work which God had made” (Gn 2:2). Avot DeRabbi Natan argues that God’s choice to describe “Let there be light” as “work” is a testament to the value of creative labor. The human capacity to work, then, is a way that we imitate God.

She again emphasizes that this is not “the soul-sucking avodah that comprises many modern lives.” Tillinger Wolkenfeld then ties all this back to AI:

Much of the debate around AI hinges on the question Can a computer do it better? But Jewish texts insist that the most important question is about process, not product. Tools that offer to replace work that I find meaningful aren’t ones I’ll be using anytime soon. … I enjoy using my creative powers to bake despite the existence of bakeries that mass-produce delicious cookies in far less time and for far less money than I can.

Some digital “solutions” don’t just steal melakhah, but also make rote tasks proliferate. Are 20 Slack messages really more efficient than one phone call? I can’t quit Slack or totally avoid email, but I can recognize them as forms of avodah and push back against their ubiquity. Technology that doesn’t allow me to devote more of my time to creative labor isn’t worth using.

7. In Christianity Today, a lovely testimony from Lindsay Holifield (who has written a few powerful pieces for this website as well). She describes the painful and all-too-familiar torments of a fundamentalist upbringing followed by a religious deconversion. The story gets especially interesting, though, “in a small closet in my Alabama apartment … There,” she writes, “I encountered the living God.” Her portrait is of a non-anxious, slow-and-steady, long-game-focused God:

This was not the aggressive blinding light that Paul met on the road to Damascus. Nor was it a heady theological argument to convince me that Jesus is God. Instead, it was a quiet but insistent knowing, a lifting of the veil to see that Jesus was the same God who had been seeking me out over the years. […]

The richness and depths of theological understanding only came after. It was many months before I began to grasp the beauty of the grand story of God’s work to make all things new. … In Jesus, I have finally found the answer I sought over the years — or rather, I should say that he found me. In him, I’ve learned that God is not a fearful, trigger-happy deity. Nor is he a bland deity with nothing to say to the evil in the world, like the narratives I heard in spaces of deconstruction. Instead, he loves his people so much that he refuses to abandon them to inevitable destruction, giving his very self to bring us back to life … My story screams of God’s long-game redemptive work that was out of sight for so long.

Strays:

subscribe to the Mockingbird newsletter

COMMENTS


2 responses to “September 14-20”

  1. David Zahl says:

    Wow, what a roundup. Zadie has got to be one of the two or three most interesting people on the planet. And that New Yorker humor piece about having relationship talks just before bed…. oyvey.

  2. JT says:

    Mickey 17 trailer looks interesting. The title immediately reminded me of the Warren Beatty film, Mickey 1, in which the refrain occurs frequently, “is there any word from the Lord?”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *