Another Week Ends

Halloween Perfectionism, Gentle Parenting (Again), the Gift of Life, and the Truth about Minimalism

Bryan Jarrell / 10.25.24

1. Spooky season is reaching its peak. In our house the pumpkins have been carved, the seeds have been roasted, and the candy has been purchased (and already broken into after the kids went to bed). Our kiddos have gotten into Batman this year, so between Amazon and Spirit Halloween, it was easy to source our collective costume situation. The pressures to come up with the perfect costume just aren’t as present when the kids are the primary focus of the holiday. 

That perfect costume pressure, especially in the internet age, is what Kate Lindsay takes umbrage with in her latest for the Atlantic: “The Chronically Online Have Stolen Halloween.” Alongside the Halloween standards and pop-culture fads, Lindsay bemoans how a certain set of meme-based, Instagram-inspired costume has both upped the holiday ante while making it less enjoyable in the process.

To give in and play Halloween by the internet’s rules results in an inevitably stressful few weeks of fall. I have to come up with a costume that’s the exact right combination of referential and recent, something that happened online in the past few months but not something that everyone else is going to be. My costume has to signal something about me, whatever inside joke I’m part of, without being a reflection of my actual interests — boring! Even if I get this right, it’ll all be to spend time at a party that’s more “Instagram set piece” than it is “Halloween get-together.” If I opt out, I risk facing a Millennial’s scariest costume of all: irrelevance.

Exorcizing the internet from Halloween, though, could resurrect the holiday’s true spirit: a cultural potluck at which all, whether Marvel or monster, are welcome. This isn’t to say that you can’t go as a meme — who am I to deny the Rayguns of the world? — but it is to say that we can drop the one-upmanship that results in a Sisyphean race for online notoriety. Like the ghosts and ghouls that adorn front lawns, Halloween can be brought back to life.

I would add to Lindsay’s argument that a second cultural force has undermined the community’s Halloween fun, which is the fandom practice of cosplay. Not only must those costumes be hand fabricated from expensive materials that require specialized training to assemble, and not only must they be franchise accurate, but the bodies of the fans dressing up must match the figure of the character they’re emulating. Frankly, if cosplay culture were a thing when I was a kid, I wouldn’t have spent hours making my DIY duct tape Boba Fett jet pack or my hand sewn Jedi robe, two costumes whose memories bring me joy twenty-five years after working on them. Perfection and performance, whether they come from picking the perfect internet meme to reference or nailing the perfect image of a video game character, ruin the best parts of Halloween: sugar, laughter, community, and a reminder of our own frailty and mortality.

2. Judging by the clicks and trends and the glut of articles we’ve written and profiled in the past year, modern-day parents are really struggling with the whole project of raising kids. This week’s addition to the collection of parenting struggle reflections comes from the Atlantic’s Olga Khazan, who spent time shadowing social media influencer and parenting consultant Chelsey Hauge-Zavaleta as she taught parents to parent while she raised her own two little kids. The report is an exploration of the gentle parenting phenomenon with all its accompanying attractions and detractors, but what stuck out to me the most was Khazan’s observation that parents are paying $5,000 for a twelve-week Zoom course for something more than parenting strategy:

After a few days with Chelsey and Robin, though, I came around to the view that their work is more than just a series of expensive scripts that you’ll strain to remember mid-meltdown. I realized that sometimes the point of this kind of program is to be not a permanent cure but a kind of ongoing emotional support. Watching Chelsey’s group-coaching sessions, I noticed that many parents seemed worried they were the only ones who couldn’t get their kids to behave. One mom, whose child had ripped something off the wall on the way out of preschool, said she feels “shame around the perceived idea that I can’t control my kid.”

As dozens of people have already warned me, parenting is the “hardest job you’ll ever have,” and I got the sense that, for her clients and TikTok followers, Chelsey is shouldering some of this intensely personal toil. There is something about Chelsey that makes people feel like it’s all going to be okay — you’re going to do better than your parents, but you’ll also mess up a lot, and that’s normal.

“In the ’90s, gentle parenting was, like, smacking your kid with the spoon instead of your hand,” said Mary Brock, one of the parents on the call. Later, she told me she likes how Chelsey and Robin listen to her, and give her encouragement without judgment. “I wish I had a gentle parent,” Brock added. “That’s what this class does for me.”

Beyond the abstractions of economics and class and success, the parents being profiled are motivated by two great desires: the explicit desire to right the wrongs of the previous generation and become better parents for their kids, and the hidden shame that comes from feeling like a parenting failure. In this light, it makes sense why well-to-do parents would invest so much money and time into a Zoom course: it’s money that helps them process their own pain with their own parents while receiving the affirmation that they are not perpetuating the cycle for their own little ones. It engenders real sympathy for modern parents, who live in a culture that tells them they are never enough, whose parents told them that they were never enough, and are haunted by their own interior voice telling them that they are not enough. Still, it has to be said that the mutual support, affirmation, and pastoral care that this course offers can be found in a (good) church for free.

3. Too heavy to offer full comment on in this column, but too significant to relegate to the “Strays” section below, we are gifted with two reflections on the power of forgiveness, death, sacrifice, and faith in the geopolitical sphere. First, there’s “How Do You Forgive the People Who Killed Your Family?,” a look into the thirty-year anniversary of the Rwandan genocide. Forgiveness is never simple or easy, especially when it is most needed, but that doesn’t mean it isn’t worth pursuing. Next, Vanity Fair reviews Alexei Navalny’s posthumous memoir, Patriot, calling it a “gospel” in which a righteous man offers himself as a sacrifice for his beloved. Navalny’s faith played a key role in his last days, as he began to have visions of Jesus who came to comfort him and prepare him for death. “Good old Jesus and the rest of his family … won’t let me down … will sort out all of my headaches. As they say in prison here: they will take my punches for me.”

4. It turns out we’ve all been lied to about Japanese minimalism. From the moment westerners forced Japanese ports open in the 1850s to Netflix specials about Marie Kondo, the reputation of Japan has been tied to a spiritual minimalism inspired by a mix of Shinto and Buddhist philosophies. Over at Aeon, Matt Alt blows the story wide open: Japanese minimalism is a matter of economics and class, and regular, everyday Japanese families have their own beloved clutter, just like the rest of us.

It has been two decades since Japan’s tidying boom began, and the nation remains as cluttered as ever. I know this because I live here. I have seen it with my own eyes, in the cities and countryside, in businesses and residences. I see it in my own home in Tokyo, typing these words from a room in which stuff relentlessly accumulates no matter how many times I clean up. Yet I don’t feel oppressed by my clutter, because it is clutter with which I have chosen to surround myself. My clutter is me.

I love the elegant simplicity of Buddhist gardens and Shintō shrines, of the tea ceremony and kaiseki cuisine. I love austere modernist architecture and product design. Yet these things have always struck me more as virtual constructs than realities. They are to be experienced in brief sojourns rather than to be lived in, like bathing in otherworldliness before returning to the humdrum reality of one’s ‘ordinary’ life. But there is something powerful that happens when we focus on the ‘ordinary’. Clutter for its own sake is not a virtue. I’m not defending the filthy or garbage-strewn. I am not embracing the unhygienic or unhinged. I’m talking about a very specific type of clutter: a cultivated sort of clutter.

Alt also interviews the author of the 1993 photo book Tokyo Style, Kyoichi Tsuzuki, who helped document the clutter of Japan for posterity. He has his own frustrations with minimalism.

‘Cluttered spaces reflect the lifestyles of their occupants,’ Tsuzuki told me. ‘Minimalism, on the other hand, is a way of establishing privacy. You can’t tell what that person wears or eats.’

‘Clutter isn’t really an East versus West thing,’ continues Tsuzuki. ‘It’s a rich versus poor thing. Wherever you go, anywhere in the world, the wealthy have the luxury of living in clean, minimal spaces, while the poor have to make do with small, cramped ones, without any way to hide their belongings.’

He continued: ‘Consider the teahouse, which so many foreign people associate with Japanese minimalism. It’s a small space with nothing inside, right? But you need to have the space to build a teahouse. You need money to build one. A minimalist space is something only those with space and money can create.’

Minimalism is, of course, a matter of class. Those traders from the 1850s never saw the average Japanese home and were only exposed to the minimalism practiced by the elites of the day. Tsuzuki’s insight that minimalism is ultimately about privacy, however, is incredibly helpful. The desire to declutter is, ultimately, the desire to avoid judgment, whether it’s the guilt of our own consumerism or the condemning eye of a visitor. And the truth is, we all judge people based on the knickknacks on the counter, the books on the shelf, and the counterspace of the kitchen. Who wouldn’t want to be free from that judgment, whether it’s judgment from outsiders or from our own self-loathing? Say what you will about Aunt Linda’s Precious Moments figurines, or your weeb nephew’s Funko Pop collection, but they’re at least comfortable enough in their own skin to let others in on their life and passions.

5. On to humor his week. McSweeney’s offers “Brutally Honest Instructions for Visiting a Pumpkin Patch,” which makes sense when you hit the ending. How about a little equal opportunity ribbing across the gender divide? The Hard Times reports “Man Debating Whether Next Short-Lived Obsession Will Be Cycling, Cast Iron or Pickling,” while Reductress reports “Woman Will Complain About Tooth Pain to Everyone She Knows Except a Dentist.” Also, Yours Truly felt seen with “Local Dad Unknowingly Performs Greatest Drum Solo of All Time on Belly of Labrador Retriever.”

6. I’m still working through why the above interview with Jenna Fischer, aka Pam from The Office, brought me to tears. I had no idea she was working through breast cancer, and according to the interview, it was news she kept private for some time. Perhaps it’s the solidarity in discovering that my millennial-era celebrities have broken bodies just like mine. Maybe it’s the striking image of “Pam” without her long flowy hair, a staple of pop culture for nearly twenty years. There’s also a lot of love and solidarity throughout the interview, from her kids, her husband, and office co-star Angela Kinsey. Either way, it’s a reminder of our collective mortality, where one reminder to get an annual checkup turns into an email on an afternoon hike that turns into a year of chemotherapy, hair loss, and exhaustion.

7. The last word this week goes to Jake Meador over at Mere Orthodoxy. Reflecting on the absence of meaning in the secular world and a renewed draw felt by many to flock to social elites of different stripes, he offers an insight from Wendell Berry and some balm from J. R. R. Tolkien to emphasize that a normal life of love and connection is not only God’s gift, but ultimately preferrable to the draws of the world. The title is great: “You Must Never Wish for Another Life.”

The world many people now live in and the only world our young have ever known is one marked both by a profound sense of powerlessness tied to a certain fear that there’s nothing worth pursuing anyway.

If that’s the world you’ve known, then I think I can see how a certain close attention to status hierarchies and ladder climbing might make sense: Membership in elite hierarchies offers the allure of wealth, power, and influence.

I almost wonder, though, if there isn’t an even more basic appeal of such hierarchies. Belonging to an elite scene or network offers not only a sense of membership and identity, but also the sense that one is part of something that’s going somewhere and that one has some part to play in it. It offers you community, work, and a destination, in other words. The wealth and status is almost more like icing on the cake at that point.

What you’re really after, as a friend put it in conversation recently, is the sense that you have a family, place, and heritage that is worthy of love, affection, and service. And since we live in the void, in the age of abandonment, anything that even faintly smells of that is intoxicating. […]

Lingering behind the lust for belonging in elite hierarchies is the sense that one owes piety to something and an almost total inability in our age of abandonment to identify the people to whom piety is owed. The best many can do is to identify people who have in some way aided them materially, even if only as an employer. Perhaps piety can be offered to them. (The more intensified form of this, of course, is the veneration one can find in pockets of American society for highly successful entrepreneurs such as Elon Musk or, before him, Steve Jobs.) […]

And how does one practice one’s devotion to God?

I began this reflection by quoting from Wendell Berry’s Hannah Coulter. Another quote might suffice in answer to that question:

“You mustn’t wish for another life. You mustn’t want to be somebody else. What you must do is this: ‘Rejoice evermore. Pray without ceasing. In everything give thanks.’ I am not all the way capable of so much, but those are the right instructions.”

If you are a Christian, then you do not need another outlet for your piety, another community to give you a sense of belonging and purpose; you have all things through Christ.

And Christ calls you into a further mystery: He calls you to the ordinary life that every Christian believer is called to — a life of rejoicing, gratitude, and prayer as you pour yourself out for the people God has given to you, all while belonging to a community bound together by water, body, and blood. Speaking of such a life, I think Tolkien spoke best: “And that will keep you as busy and as happy as anyone can be, as long as your part of the Story goes on.”

Strays:

  • Mockingbird’s own Jason Thompson reflects on the 30th anniversary of Quentin Tarantino’s Pulp Fiction. Don’t let the director’s stylized violence fool you: Pulp Fiction is a move about God’s mercy and redemption. Included is a blurb from the Tarantino chapter in our 2015 book Mockingbird at the Movies (that Yours Truly happened to write for).
  • Freya India is quickly becoming one of my favorite writers with her insights into the struggles of Gen Z life. If you haven’t checked out her latest, “The Age of Abandonment,” a look into why her peers have such trouble with commitment, I encourage you to do so.
  • “If one of the most famous rock stars on the planet is playing the best shows of his life, and no one is there to witness it — is he really playing them?” Seen & Unseen reflecting on Jack White’s small venue No Name tour.
  • “When I talk about humility, what I mean, in part, is recognizing that we do not get circumstances that are always exactly to our liking.” Mike Cosper at Christianity Today interviews New York Times writer Frank Bruni.
subscribe to the Mockingbird newsletter

COMMENTS


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *