The Trouble With True Crime Podcasts

My mind conjures enough trouble by itself.

Ali Holcomb / 11.7.24

It can be fun to be afraid. When I was growing up, the neighborhood crew and I would look over at the bushes in the corner of my yard that were mysterious and shadowy and we’d tell tales that nodded to the headless horseman in Legend of Sleepy Hollow (the short story, not the movie). Of course, it wasn’t true, but it was fun to have your heart beat a little faster looking over at the shadows, letting your imagination spook you just a little, all the while knowing you would go inside at the end of the night and be warm and safe. I love a cozy British mystery show, a pretty, quaint village with a murder whodunit. And I adore Agatha Christie. Most of her books are cozy mysteries, but there are a few that are dark, and I don’t mind being a little scared.

For years, I listened to the frights of true crime podcasts, but not anymore.

The podcasts were ghastly and interesting, horrific tales being told either in soothing, serious voices, or in a lighthearted manner. It’s true that women seem to be particularly drawn to these podcasts, and it’s been widely speculated as to why this is. Perhaps because the victims are often women and we think if we listen to it enough, we can avoid the scenarios. Listening to these podcasts lets us face fear in a controlled way (I’ve heard this used from people who enjoy horror movies as well). I never felt guilty for listening to them though. Most women do and why does it matter? I remember when I told my then boyfriend (now husband) that I loved true crime podcasts, he gave me a skeptical side-eye. “I just don’t like to think about that stuff, too dark,” he said. I found it hard to mount a strong defense for listening, but I continued.

About a year and a half ago on a road trip by myself, I listened solely to True Crime podcasts for essentially five hours straight. It was a bit much, and I haven’t listened to them since. And to be honest, I am just now exploring why I stopped. At first, I chalked it up to listening to it for too many hours and getting burned out, but now I think it was a subconscious choice for peace.

I’m wired to fret and make myself anxious. I jump to worst-case scenarios when the future is the most uncertain. Whether I realize it or not, I often choose to spiral. It’s not so much that I pause at a fork in the road and say, “I can either be calm or I can freak out.” I don’t even really give my mind that chance to pause and choose, I just let gravity take me down my spiral, even though I am not someone who often jumps to scenarios of being kidnapped or murdered when walking alone, and I don’t startle at noises when I’m alone in our house.

I always assumed that listening to true crime podcasts was harmless. But I am prone to jumping to conclusions, to my own darkness, and I’ve found that those podcasts push me further down those paths. Okay, so a true crime podcast doesn’t cause me to walk around the house with a frying pan at night looking for a serial killer. But one night when I was waiting on the side of the road for three hours with a broken-down car, I did despair and start crying, even after speaking with a AAA representative who assured me someone was on their way. I convinced myself they had bad directions and wouldn’t be able to find me. I have also gone on WebMD for a minor headache, because what if I was actually going blind?

When you type these scenarios out they seem silly, but subconsciously I have conditioned myself to ponder the worst-case scenario. For the long months of the past year when I was doing long-distance marriage over a deployment, I told myself for that period I wouldn’t use WebMD to look up my symptoms. I went to the doctor and the dentist for normal checkups, and when I received a clean bill of health, I’d believe the diagnosis rather than wonder if they’d missed something. Subconsciously I chose not to listen to crime podcasts during that period of time. It was a period where it would be easy to spiral, but I had few guardrails set up to keep my mind on track.

The verse in Philippians 4 is one I hear often as an anxious person, “Finally, brothers and sisters, whatever is true, whatever is noble, whatever is right, whatever is pure, whatever is lovely, whatever is admirable — if anything is excellent or praiseworthy — think about such things.” I have always thought it was a nice verse, but perhaps a little unrealistic. We can’t just sit and ponder good things all day long. We are in a fallen world, we need to confront hard truths. And also, no one wants to watch a story with no plot. There needs to be some conflict and turmoil for it to be interesting. But the stories I like the most are compelling even in the midst of hardship. Seeing the hobbits be brave in Lord of the Rings is a noble thing to think on. Watching Winters lead his men in the trenches on D-Day in Band of Brothers is admirable. We aren’t to shun all fears and doubts, but let us at least look to stories of hope that make us yearn to be brave.

The trouble with true crime podcasts has more to do with us. It’s not that God wants us to dwell in a bubble of positive thinking, but he knows what is in our hearts. As Jesus taught in Mark 7, out of our hearts comes the sin that defiles. He knows that because we are finite creatures who cannot control our circumstances, we are prone to fretting and anxiety. He knows how little it takes to send us spiraling down paths from which we cannot pull ourselves out. We will not think of the truth but will be drawn to the lies we tell ourselves. We naturally think of the bleak, the dark, and the depressing, and because of this we will not be armed to fight our grief when our circumstances are hard. And for me at least, true crime podcasts awaken in me more than the curiosities of entertainment.

I’ve found my mind conjures enough trouble by itself. I want to be a more peaceful and more hopeful person, and I don’t need any help imagining the worst-case scenario. I’d rather my mind drift in other directions, and that means avoiding what I’ve found can lead to spiraling. If true crime podcasts are mindless to you and haven’t caused spiraling, then by all means, continue to listen to them! But for me, I think I’ll stick with Miss Marple.

subscribe to the Mockingbird newsletter

COMMENTS


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *