Nothing but Misconceptions Between You and Your Calvin

This comes to us from our very own resident Mockingcalvinist, Michael Cooper. We thought that […]

JDK / 5.26.10

This comes to us from our very own resident Mockingcalvinist, Michael Cooper. We thought that we would take this day to remember one of our other favorite Reformers, John Calvin. . . not that we had a choice, mind you:) Enjoy!

On May 26 the Church of England commemorates John Calvin as a saint of the church. Not much reason to celebrate, some might say. Let’s have a parade for the Karl Rove of the Reformation, the more sardonic might suggest. B.G Armstrong pretty much sums up the picture John Calvin evokes in the minds of many:

Except among his followers, he has been portrayed as a cold, unfeeling, and calculating man, who imposed his stern will on helpless or cowed people. He is seen as the proponent of an austere and joyless religion of fear and constraint, and of a vengeful and arbitrary omnipotent God who treats human beings as puppets, demanding of them servile obedience, yet severely punishing the slightest deviation from his strict moral code. “

Calvin is seen in stark contrast to the “kinder and gentler” Luther who, except for his rants against the papists, is viewed as a jolly beer drinking German peasant good ol’ boy friend of sinners, while Calvin assumes the role of a pinched up parsing FRENCH LAWYER (enough said) ready to pound the poor Christian with a good whack of the law to keep him in line. Armstrong correctly points out that “Such a legalistic and negativistic religion, popularly attributed to Calvin, is a ridiculous caricature that recent scholarship has only begun to correct. “

So, this being Calvin’s “day” so to speak, I thought that I would give you a little “Calvin sampler” , and let you be the judge of whether Jean Calvin had an understanding of Jesus as the friend of sinners, even Christian sinners:

“Surely, with good reason the Heavenly Father affirms that the only stronghold of safety is in calling upon his name. By so doing we invoke the presence both of his providence, through which he watches over and guards our affairs, and of his power, through which he sustains us, weak as we are and well-nigh overcome, and of his goodness, through which he receives us, miserably burdened with sins, unto grace; and, in short, it is by prayer that we call him to reveal himself as wholly present to us. Hence comes an extraordinary peace and repose to our consciences. For having disclosed to the Lord the necessity that was pressing upon us, we even rest fully in the thought that none of our ills are hid from him who, we are convinced, has both the will and the power to take the best care of us.”

and

“But ‘assurance’ I do not understand to mean that which soothes our mind with sweet and perfect repose, releasing it from every anxiety. For to repose so peacefully is the part of those who, when all affairs are flowing to their liking, are touched by no care, burn with no desire, toss with no fear. But for the saints the occasion that best stimulates them to call upon God is when, distressed by their own need, they are troubled by the greatest unrest, and are almost driven out of their senses, until faith opportunely comes to their relief. For among such tribulations God’s goodness so shines upon them that even when they groan with weariness under the weight of present ills, and also are troubled and tormented by the fear of greater ones, yet, relying upon his goodness , they are relieved of the difficulty of bearing them, and are solaced and hope for escape and deliverance.”

This is not to argue that Calvin had no flaws, or that he had it all figured out, or that he was not a severely “cracked vessel” just like the rest of us. But with all that said, I for one still have to say, on this May 26th: Thanks be to God for our dear brother, John Calvin.

subscribe to the Mockingbird newsletter

COMMENTS


11 responses to “Nothing but Misconceptions Between You and Your Calvin”

  1. StampDawg says:

    Thanks to the Hammer for this. Very touching — I am gonna keep these.

  2. Keith Pozzuto says:

    Good ole Johny Boy, It is true so many of us bash the man but he like us was moved by the mercies of God. Thank you for a little course correction

  3. Margaret E says:

    I loved this post! As a former atheist turned accidental Presbyterian (long story), I've been doing a lot of reading on Calvin lately, and recently saw a wonderful documentary about him at church. It made the same point as this post – that we've had Calvin all wrong. My heart was really warmed by what I learned…

  4. Margaret E says:

    P.S. I especially love the "Unconditional Change" poster!

  5. Michael Cooper says:

    Thanks all… and Margaret E, "accidental Presbyterian" has to be my favorite oxymoron of all time!!!

  6. Margaret E says:

    LOL. Well, I first went there after a Christmas performance of Handel's Messiah… mainly just wanted to sing in their choir. Had no idea what I was getting myself into, theology-wise. (Most of the members of my church STILL have no idea, I fear…) There are many things I like about the Presbies, and some that I don't. I'm fairly attached to the Episcopal church next door, too. Kinda "playing the field," I guess you could say 🙂

  7. Nathan says:

    John Calvin has had a far greater impact on the church AND on world history than Luther has. There, I said it. 🙂

    PS. It's true.

  8. Michael Cooper says:

    Nathan–and for sure a greater impact on modern French prose 🙂

  9. Mike Demmon says:

    I find this a little funny, as in the Episcopal Church USA today is Augustine of Canterbury, the first Archbishop thereof, who successfully "converted" all the British Christians and Anglo-Saxons pagans to Roman Christianity.

    John Calvin is May 28th, for Trial Use only apparently. There has got to be a joke in that.

  10. Jacob says:

    If anyone is interesting there is a new easy to read biography on Calvin by W. Robert Godfrey entitled John Calvin Pilgrim and Pastor.

    For the record I still think Michael Horton has the best and most gracious understanding of Calvin out there.

  11. L.R.E. Larkin says:

    michael: great post…really. I have a soft spot in my heart for him and his theology. he was a man who was deeply and profoundly aware of his brokenness (as well as a man of deep sorrows, having lost his wife and his son, correct?). His doctrine of the knowledge of God is the best stuff I've read…and has had tremendous impact on some of my favorite theologians like Barth…anyway…as a fairly die-hard lutheran as I am, there's room for Calvin. again, thanks for this.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *